Do students have the right to see how their papers were graded?

Academia Asked by BCLC on January 13, 2021

I read Academia varies more than you think it does, but in any school or university I’ve been to or heard of, students can always see how they were graded for any assignment. Or, at least, if the school won’t let them keep it, but they will at least let the students view it.

I believe it’s every student’s right to know how they were graded on, well, a graded requirement. (see Dan Fox and David Hill‘s answers) The only exception I can think of is Educational Testing Service, which administers the TOEFL and GRE, but it’s not really a school or anything.

Recently, my sibling was a little surprised with a grade on a paper and wants to know about how their particular paper was graded. But when my sibling tried to ask to view the marking of the paper, this was the reply:

[University] does not provide marks to students after the examination. The only thing that can be released is the Grade or Pass/Fail. Giving you the marks would be a violation of the regulations. In fact, all such information will be destroyed after a period of time. You can try asking other teachers about marks, they will also tell you the same.

Do/Should students have the right to see their how exams were graded?

Is this policy unconventional or unethical or unfair? Based on
Corvus’ answer to this

and Dan Fox’s answer to this
I kind of think my sibling’s university’s policy is unconventional
or something.

How will any student get feedback on their communication or their mistakes if they do not see any of the marking of their

(more details in old revision of post)

One Answer

I doubt that this is a case of a student "offending" an individual professor and more one of rules in place that may not make sense and that you may not approve of, but still, rules.

I don't like, personally, such rules. I think they are wrong, but an individual professor has little actual control over rule making. They may not be willing to break the rules, especially if they are a junior faculty member.

Personally, I probably wouldn't give back final exams, though I did give back all others. But I would certainly let a student look over the grading. But I was bound by no such rules.

And, note that, depending on the scale of the institution, it might be very difficult to permit students access to final exams. When I was a TA, we graded Calculus finals as a group, with each TA grading only one problem. So, a student's grade was an amalgam of judgements. We were guided by a rubric, of course. But the professor didn't grade the finals and so might find it difficult to respond to exactly why a point (or ten) was lost. Smaller institutions can "afford" a more personal touch and usually strive to do so. It should be (perfect world) possible for larger ones to do so also, but often don't. And if there were a few hundred students, it is difficult to respond to individuals, just for the time it takes. Ideal. No.

Intermediate exams are a different matter, in my view, since they can and should be used to guide the student's learning. But, Rules.

And usually, by enrolling in a university, the student makes an implicit (at least) agreement to abide by the rules in place.

Answered by Buffy on January 13, 2021

Add your own answers!

Related Questions

Can NSF fund Lecturers?

1  Asked on October 21, 2021 by john-tavers


Does it make sense to translate my bachelor’s thesis?

1  Asked on February 27, 2021 by moonknight


Cite or reformulate perfectly formulated sentences?

2  Asked on January 29, 2021 by student0284


Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2023 All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP