# Why don't (or can't) stars be more than 325 or so times the mass of the sun? What limits their size?

Astronomy Asked on January 4, 2022

Is there a particular reason why stars cannot grow as massive as they want to?

And why doesn’t this limit apply to supermassive black holes?

There is basically an upper limit to the mass of a star because their luminosity is so great that the radiation pressure prevents the accretion of further mass.

However, the upper limit depends on the composition of the accreting material. This is because the effect of the radiation depends on the opacity of the material - stuff that is more metal-rich is more opaque. The upper limit you refer to is a bit too high for compositions similar to the Sun (I think more like $$200 M_odot$$ would be the limit for that). For stars born in the distant past that were metal-poor, or even born from primordial material with no metals, the upper limit could be much higher.

For primordial material, with no metals at all, the physics that determines the upper limit is likely to be fragmentation. Primordial gas is quite transparent to radiation, but this also means it is poor at radiating away the heat from gravitational contraction. In principle, much larger bodies can only begin to contract towards being very massive stars if some of the gas is ionised or if there is hydrogen in molecular form. However, this cooling also reduces the Jeans mass, allowing the collapsing cloud to fragment into a cluster of smaller objects before a supermassive $$(>10^6 M_odot)$$ star/black hole could form.

Nobody knows for sure how supermassive black holes formed. It seems likely that they grew from seed intermediate black holes that formed from very massive primordial stars - perhaps thousands of solar masses - or even by direct collapse to black holes of mass $$10^4-10^6 M_odot$$ without ever forming a stable star.

Answered by ProfRob on January 4, 2022

## Related Questions

### Where do we define the “surface” of a gas planet?

2  Asked on September 28, 2021 by carlos-vzquez-monzn

### How can I correct for transit time?

1  Asked on September 28, 2021 by perplexeddimension

### What does BJD-2450000 mean?

3  Asked on September 28, 2021 by laila

### Why didn’t we see those campfires on the Sun until now?

1  Asked on September 28, 2021

### How far from Betelgeuse is its habitable zone?

3  Asked on September 28, 2021

### Observing cepheid variables in other galaxies

1  Asked on September 28, 2021 by arinla

### What does “the depth of the 13.0 Å feature differs by 7 sigma from zero” mean?

1  Asked on September 28, 2021 by chen

### Do Enceladus’ geysers fall back to its surface or do they achieve escape velocity?

1  Asked on September 28, 2021

### How does Io’s atmosphere behave locally near volcanic plumes?

1  Asked on September 28, 2021

### Comet Neowise c2020 f3 will return in ~6800 years, how can we be sure Earth will be in the right place to see it then?

3  Asked on September 28, 2021

### Catalogs for type K stars and their planetary systems?

1  Asked on September 28, 2021

### Can any satellite train still be seen?

1  Asked on September 28, 2021

### Can telescopes determine whether Hygiea is in hydrostatic equilibrium?

0  Asked on September 28, 2021 by ioannes

### Why don’t the inner moons of Jupiter have tidally-induced volcanism?

3  Asked on September 28, 2021

### If the Sun’s trajectory were altered, would the solar system follow?

2  Asked on September 28, 2021 by jack-rod

### Would DCBH form supermassive stars first before BH formation

1  Asked on September 28, 2021 by notsosn

### Closest stable orbit about the sun of an asteroid?

2  Asked on September 28, 2021 by bob516

### Does the axial tilt of Mercury and Venus vary?

1  Asked on September 28, 2021

### Stars in star clusters in SMC and LMC

2  Asked on February 24, 2021 by mycrofd