# Application of limiting reagents and acid-base stoichiometry

Chemistry Asked by user29462 on February 25, 2021

I’m having a bit of trouble with the latter questions of this problem.

$$pu{15.0 mL}$$ of $$pu{1.4 M}$$ $$ce{HCl}$$ was mixed with $$pu{1.00 g}$$ of $$ce{CaCO3}$$ until all the solid had dissolved. The solution was then transferred to a conical flask and made up to $$pu{200 mL}$$ with water. A $$pu{20.0 mL}$$ portion of this solution was then neutralized by $$pu{8.50 mL}$$ of a $$pu{0.100 M}$$ $$ce{NaOH}$$ solution.
Calculate:

1. Amount of substance in excess of $$ce{HCl}$$ in the $$pu{20.0 mL}$$ portion
2. Amount of substance in excess of $$ce{HCl}$$ in the $$pu{200.0 mL}$$ portion
3. Amount of substance in excess of $$ce{HCl}$$ which reacted with $$ce{CaCO3}$$

My approach

$$ce{2HCl(aq) + CaCO3(s) -> CaCl2(aq) + H2O(l) + CO2(g)}$$

Finding the amount of substance of each reactant and hence the limiting reactant,

For $$ce{HCl}$$:
begin{align} M[ce{HCl}] &= frac{mathrm{mol}}{mathrm{L}}\ mathrm{mol}[ce{HCl}] &= mathrm{M}times mathrm{L}\ therefore mathrm{mol}[ce{HCl}] &= 1.4times (15.0times 10^{-3}) = 0.021 end{align}

For $$ce{CaCO_3}$$:
begin{align} mathrm{mol}[ce{CaCO_3}] &= frac{mathrm{m}}{mathrm{mm}}\ mathrm{mol}[ce{CaCO_3}] &= frac{1.00}{100.0869 }\ therefore mathrm{mol}[ce{CaCO_3}] &= 9.9913times10^{-3} end{align}

Therefore (after dividing by stoichiometric coefficients) $$ce{CaCO_3}$$ is limiting.

From here I’m not sure if what I did next is correct. I found the amount of substance of $$ce{CaCl_2}$$ produced the remaining $$ce{HCl}$$ in excess. Which were,

begin{align} mathrm{mol}[ce{CaCl_2}] &= 9.9913times10^{-3} text{ and,}\ mathrm{mol}[ce{HCl}] &= 1.1009times10^{-2} end{align}

(Meaning that we have $$9.9913times10^{-3}mathrm{mol}$$ of $$ce{CaCl_2}$$ and $$1.1009times10^{-2}mathrm{mol}$$ of $$ce{HCl}$$ in in $$pu{15 mL}$$ of solution?)

From here on I’m stumped.

This problem looks like a typical job, that I have often given in the lab sessions to my high school classes. The student has to analyze a sample of chalk, which is made of CaCO3, plus some insoluble impurities like alumina $$ce{Al2O3}$$, silica $$ce{SiO2}$$ or gypsum $$ce{CaSO4·2H2O}$$. So the student adds an excess of $$ce{HCl}$$, waits until no effervescence is observed, and then titrate the excess of $$ce{HCl}$$ with a standard $$ce{NaOH}$$ solution. This is what was done here.

Here the titration shows that the sample contains $$0.625$$ g pure $$ce{CaCO3}$$. So it is a rather impure sample, with only $$62.5$$ % $$ce{CaCO3}$$. This may happen.

Answered by Maurice on February 25, 2021

I understand the procedure but not the questions. So there are two reactions:

$$ce{2HCl(aq) + CaCO3(s) -> H2CO3(aq) + 2 Cl-(aq) + Ca2+(aq)}$$ $$ce{HCl(aq) + NaOH(aq) -> H2O(l) + Cl-(aq) + Na+(aq)}$$

The first reaction has reactants in non-stoichiometric amounts. The second reaction, a titration, is done with stoichiometric amounts, yielding a neutral reaction mixture.

The strange thing is that the problem is over-determined: I can calculate the amount of HCl not neutralized by calcium carbonate either by looking at the amounts of the two (assuming the reaction goes to completion) or by the titration (assuming that neutralizing means to add sufficient NaOH to be at stoichiometry ratio with the remaining HCl).

There is also a technical detail: it would be better to boil off the carbonic acid made by protonating the carbonate. Otherwise, the analyte will contain strong and weak acid, and buffer will form during the titration (with the endpoint of the titration ill-defined: is it when the HCl is depleted, or when all acid is depleted?).

However, it seems like the question wants us to make an argument about amounts starting with the titration. We will assume that the titration and the reaction between $$ce{CaCO3 and HCl}$$ go to completion, and chalk up (get it?) any inconsistencies to impure $$ce{CaCO3}$$.

Amount of NaOH

$$c_{mathrm{ce{NaOH}}} = 0.100 mathrm{M}$$

$$n_{mathrm{ce{NaOH}}} = c_{mathrm{ce{NaOH}}} cdot V_{mathrm{ce{NaOH}}}$$

$$=0.100 mathrm{M} cdot 8.50 mathrm{mL}$$

$$=8.50times 10^{-4} mathrm{mol}$$

Amount of HCl

The amount of HCl in the 20 mL sample was $$pu{8.50e-4 mol}$$ (from the titration). So the amount in the entire 200 mL sample after adding carbonate was $$pu{8.50e-3 mol}$$. The amount used up by reacting with carbonate is the difference between the original amount, $$pu{0.021 mol}$$ or $$pu{21e-3 mol}$$, and what is left after the first reaction.

$$n_mathrm{reacted} = pu{21e-3 mol} - pu{8.50e-3 mol} = pu{12.5e-3 mol}$$

Amount of $$ce{CaCO3}$$

As the OP writes, there is a 2:1 stoichiometry (HCl vs $$ce{CaCO3}$$), so

$$n_ce{CaCO3} = pu{12.5e-3 mol} / 2 = pu{6.2e-3 mol}$$

On the other hand, if the sample were 100% and everything has 100% yield and we had boiled off the carbonic acid, we would expect a higher amount in 1.00 g of calcium carbonate, i.e. $$pu{9.99e-3 mol}$$ as correctly pointed out by the OP.

Why the discrepancy?

Answered by Karsten Theis on February 25, 2021

## Related Questions

### Stubborn CuAAC reaction as derivatization for ESI-MS

1  Asked on January 18, 2021

### Common ion effect

0  Asked on January 16, 2021 by satwik

### Rate of solvolysis of allyl and alkyl halides

1  Asked on January 14, 2021

### Is there a difference between oxidation state and valency?

1  Asked on January 14, 2021 by isaac_samuel

### Bond angles in NH3 and NCl3

3  Asked on January 11, 2021 by kirti-agrawal

### How do I get the smell of Febreeze (uncomplexed cyclodextrin composition) out of my carpet?

0  Asked on January 9, 2021 by annette-r

### Why does magnesium bromide transfers from a carbon atom to nitrogen in piperidine?

1  Asked on January 9, 2021

### Calculation of rupture force in a covalent bond

1  Asked on January 8, 2021 by donghwi-min

### Alphanumeric preference between hexyl and heptyl

1  Asked on January 6, 2021

### Hydrogen venting: Why no flame arrestors?

2  Asked on January 5, 2021 by curious_cat

### Negative DBE/Degree of Hydrogen Deficiency?

0  Asked on January 4, 2021 by uchuuko

### How can we tell if a substitution reaction will be thermodynamically favoured

0  Asked on January 2, 2021 by ali-rizwan

### Dynamic viscosity of gas mixture (appropriate estimation)

0  Asked on December 31, 2020 by josh-e

### My Misconception of Entropy

1  Asked on December 31, 2020 by dval98

### Calcium chloride + starch desiccant packs inside PPE for ebola workers?

0  Asked on December 30, 2020 by jason-holt

### Why is maximum buffer capacity for some diprotic buffers not when pH = pKa?

1  Asked on December 29, 2020 by yeryeon-seo

### Using Beer-Lambert law to calculate light intensities

1  Asked on December 23, 2020 by lblindner

### Converting bromobenzene to 1‐bromo‐3‐methylbenzene

1  Asked on December 23, 2020 by rover

### Coordination compound nomenclature for [Cu(acac)(bpy)]BPh4

0  Asked on December 21, 2020 by marina-calder

### Why are alkali metal compounds like sodium hydride or sodium amide strong bases but weak nucleophiles?

1  Asked on December 19, 2020 by normoorgo