# Bond Lengths: Equatorial vs Axial in Trigonal Bipyramidal

Chemistry Asked by Sourav Suman on October 31, 2020

Why is it that the axial bond length is less than equatorial bond length in $ce{PF2Cl3}$ and $ce{SF2Cl2}$ even though both have trigonal bi-pyramidal geometry?

I know that in general axial bond length is greater than equatorial bond length in trigonal bi-pyramidal structures (as in the case of $ce{PCl5}$). (See: PBP vs TBP geometry?)

For trigonal bipyramidal structure, we know that lone pairs are preferred first to be positioned in the equatorial position. So in $$ce{SF2Cl2}$$ lone pairs will be positioned in the equatorial position.

After placing lone pairs in the equatorial position, double bonds are then preferred in the equatorial position but as there are no double bonds in the structures we are considering, so we jump on to the next rule i.e. atoms having higher electronegativity is positioned at axial position and atoms having low electronegativity is positioned at equatorial position. You can also interpret this in another way. You can also say that atoms having higher atomic size is positioned in the equatorial plane and atoms having lower atomic size is positioned in the axial plane.

Now coming back to your structures, $$ce{PF2Cl3}$$ and $$ce{SF2CL2}$$ we will see structures in this manner:

$$ce{F}$$ is more electronegative than $$ce{Cl}$$, hence the $$ce{P-F}$$ bonds are going to be shorter than $$ce{P-Cl}$$ bonds and $$ce{S-F}$$ bonds are going to be shorter than $$ce{S-Cl}$$ bonds. As $$ce{F}$$s (fluorines) are located in the axial position, hence these $$ce{P-F}$$ or $$ce{S-F}$$ bonds which are actually axial bonds are shorter than that of equatorial bonds (i.e. $$ce{P-Cl}$$ or $$ce{S-Cl}$$ bonds).

In $$ce{PCl5}$$ all the atoms around $$ce{P}$$ are basically the same i.e. $$ce{Cl}$$. So the electronegativity factor of $$ce{Cl}$$ doesn't play any role in reasoning out why axial bonds are longer than equatorial bonds in case $$ce{PCl5}$$. The reason is - in $$ce{PCl5}$$ the axial bonds suffer repulsion from the equatorial bonds so they become long. The equatorial bonds providing repulsion to axial bonds also happens in case of $$ce{PF3Cl3}$$ and $$ce{SF2Cl2}$$, however this factor is overlooked/ not considered in cases of $$ce{PF2Cl3}$$ and $$ce{SF2Cl2}$$ because there this factor/ effect is not dominating. In those cases as the type of atoms attached (i.e. electronegative atoms) are different, hence the effect of bond length shortening due to the electronegative atom attached is the dominating factor.

Correct answer by Yb609 on October 31, 2020

## Related Questions

### Stubborn CuAAC reaction as derivatization for ESI-MS

1  Asked on January 18, 2021

### Common ion effect

0  Asked on January 16, 2021 by satwik

### Rate of solvolysis of allyl and alkyl halides

1  Asked on January 14, 2021

### Is there a difference between oxidation state and valency?

1  Asked on January 14, 2021 by isaac_samuel

### Bond angles in NH3 and NCl3

3  Asked on January 11, 2021 by kirti-agrawal

### How do I get the smell of Febreeze (uncomplexed cyclodextrin composition) out of my carpet?

0  Asked on January 9, 2021 by annette-r

### Why does magnesium bromide transfers from a carbon atom to nitrogen in piperidine?

1  Asked on January 9, 2021

### Calculation of rupture force in a covalent bond

1  Asked on January 8, 2021 by donghwi-min

### Alphanumeric preference between hexyl and heptyl

1  Asked on January 6, 2021

### Hydrogen venting: Why no flame arrestors?

2  Asked on January 5, 2021 by curious_cat

### Negative DBE/Degree of Hydrogen Deficiency?

0  Asked on January 4, 2021 by uchuuko

### How can we tell if a substitution reaction will be thermodynamically favoured

0  Asked on January 2, 2021 by ali-rizwan

### Dynamic viscosity of gas mixture (appropriate estimation)

0  Asked on December 31, 2020 by josh-e

### My Misconception of Entropy

1  Asked on December 31, 2020 by dval98

### Calcium chloride + starch desiccant packs inside PPE for ebola workers?

0  Asked on December 30, 2020 by jason-holt

### Why is maximum buffer capacity for some diprotic buffers not when pH = pKa?

1  Asked on December 29, 2020 by yeryeon-seo

### Using Beer-Lambert law to calculate light intensities

1  Asked on December 23, 2020 by lblindner

### Converting bromobenzene to 1‐bromo‐3‐methylbenzene

1  Asked on December 23, 2020 by rover

### Coordination compound nomenclature for [Cu(acac)(bpy)]BPh4

0  Asked on December 21, 2020 by marina-calder

### Why are alkali metal compounds like sodium hydride or sodium amide strong bases but weak nucleophiles?

1  Asked on December 19, 2020 by normoorgo