TransWikia.com

DNS simulation in industry

Computational Science Asked by user36293 on October 24, 2020

I have this idea in my mind that Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) is only used in research since the Reynolds numbers of industrial applications are too high and require computer horsepower we don’t have yet. Is that still true nowadays?

Any reference on the subject?

One Answer

I believe this is too broad to be answered here, but DNS has already been employed for high Reynolds number simulations in the range of 12,000 < Re < 33,500 - for swirling jets, but still "out of reach for large systems".

In order to visualize the size of scales required to capture turbulent flow parameters for a high Reynolds number flow, let's take for example a simple air flow in a pipe with $text{Re} approx 10^5$ having fairly moderate turbulence intensity of 3%.

Now, the most important factor to take into consideration for DNS and LES is the smallest eddies (Kolmogorov eddy) scale, those are the smallest scales of eddies that can exist in a turbulent flow before being converted into heat through viscous dissipation and your DNS simulation should capture such eddies.

(I am not going to include all the calculations to make the answer concise, but you can refer to Wilcox (2006) and Rodriguez (2019) for more).

Now, back to our flow situation, you are expecting to have Kolmogorov scales with the following estimations:

Kolmogorov eddy length scale     0.000152879 [meters]
Kolmogorov eddy time scale       0.00148359  [seconds]
Kolmogorov eddy velocity scale   0.103046    [meter/second]

So, you basically have an idea about the vast size of the mesh and the time step required to have a Courant number less than one. And higher Reynolds number will have even smaller scales (imagine having a DNS setup for a supersonic flow over a 3D wing).

However, I believe this paragraph by Rodriguez (2019), might give you an insight about the future of DNS (which is very very limited right now):

In any case, as computational power increases, DNS will not only be used for turbulence research and small systems but for larger engineering designs as well; this trend is inevitable and was predicted long ago. This optimistic premise is supported by the strong potential from recent advances in quantum computers, topological quantum materials, and quantum algorithms [...] quantum algorithms already solve linear systems of equations, which are essential for CFD solvers.

Furthermore, it is expected that quantum algorithms will result in an exponential decrease of the time required to solve systems of linear equations. Indeed, the literature as of 2019 indicates the potential for computational speed increases of at least a factor of 1000! And of course, the detailed DNS calculations will uncover fluid functionality that can be leveraged onto vastly improved engineered system behavior and performance.

I really can't recommend this book enough (specifically for your question): Applied Computational Fluid Dynamics and Turbulence Modeling - Rodriguez (2019)

Correct answer by Algo on October 24, 2020

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP