TransWikia.com

Do we need to demean and standardize all variables in a model?

Cross Validated Asked by Ama Perera on November 29, 2021

I am analyzing a panel data set with 55 countries. The coefficient of my variable of interest is not naturally interpret able. Hence, I thought of demeaning and standardizing my dependent and independent variable.

My questions are;
01) Is it Ok to standardize only the dependent and independent variable? Do I need to standardize the control variables in my model when running the regression?
02) When running the regression with demeaned and standardized variables, is it correct to use “reg” c instead of “xtreg” in Stata?

One Answer

I am not a proponent of standardizing coefficients in panel data contexts. But, hopefully others will offer their input.

Is it [okay] to standardize only the dependent and independent variable?

You can, but what is your justification for doing this? For instance, you already noted that you intend to demean your data. By construction, you are restricting attention to "within-country" effects. Standardizing your coefficients (i.e., calculating $beta$ coefficients) after the "within transformation" would inevitably be a "pooled" standard deviation that incorporates cross-country information.

In other words, you begin with a fixed effects estimation strategy to center each country around a "within-country" time average, but then you use the entire panel to standardize your coefficients. It seems paradoxical.

2) When running the regression with demeaned and standardized variables, is it correct to use "reg" c instead of "xtreg" in Stata?

I am unaware of any built-in Stata commands to standardize your demeaned data within each panel unit. In my opinion, you must be very clear about what variation you are using to identify your effects. In your case, one transformation uses within-country variation, while the other invariably uses between-country variation. It is unclear what variation will dominate in your regression.

Consistent with Alex's comments, I would investigate the interpretive value of a log-log model. Proportional percentage changes might ease the interpretability of the model coefficients.

Answered by Thomas Bilach on November 29, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP