# Example of mean independent variables but dependent still

Cross Validated Asked by luchonacho on December 11, 2020

Econometric textbooks often make the distinction between three types of independence:

1. Stochastic independence: $$mathrm{D}(u|x)=mathrm{D}(u)$$
2. Mean independence: $$mathrm{E}(u|x)=mathrm{E}(u)$$
3. Linear independence: $$mathrm{Cov}(u,x)=0$$

with the one preceding being stronger and implying the subsequent. For instance, Wooldridge (2002, p.22) states:

We also need to know how the notion of statistical independence relates to conditional expectations. If $$u$$ is a random variable independent of the random vector $$x$$,
then $$mathrm{E}(u|x)=mathrm{E}(u)$$, so that if $$mathrm{E}(u)= 0$$ and $$u$$ and $$x$$ are independent, then $$mathrm{E}(u|x) = 0$$. The converse of this is not true: $$mathrm{E}(u|x)=mathrm{E}(u)$$ does not imply statistical independence between $$u$$ and $$x$$ (just as zero correlation between $$u$$ and $$x$$ does not imply independence).

It is easy to come with examples of uncorrelated random variables that are not (mean) independent. $$Y=X^2$$ is a classic one. Many questions on this site cover others (e.g. here).

What I’m struggling with is to think of an example of two variables which are mean independent but dependent more generally. I wonder whether this is merely a technical point or we are against a true possibility in science. I don’t even know how to start to simulate an example of such joint distribution. Independent on mean but dependent on variance? Maybe something from finance? Any ideas on this?

## Related Questions

### Why does a class weight fraction improve precision compared to undersampling approach where precision drops?

1  Asked on November 12, 2021

### Is it possible to implement an activation function or layer in Keras that uses two distinct sets of weights?

1  Asked on November 12, 2021

### Expert Knowledge Acquisition and Machine learning

1  Asked on November 12, 2021

### Improving F1 scores using models with good precision and recall

1  Asked on November 12, 2021

### Is ROCR applied to training data or testing data?

1  Asked on November 12, 2021 by fcas80

### Is the plot “White noise”?

0  Asked on November 12, 2021

### Multilabel Tweet Classification

0  Asked on November 12, 2021 by vineet

### Propagating uncertainty through nested random forest models

0  Asked on November 12, 2021

### Identify a contaminated distribution

1  Asked on November 12, 2021 by stephen-clark

### How do we generate the samples of hidden root nodes in the Bayes network (Sigmoid Belief Networks) of a generative model

1  Asked on November 12, 2021 by user6703592

### Which monotone transformations give a very loose confidence interval in transformed space?

0  Asked on November 12, 2021

### Restricted standard deviation of survival time

1  Asked on November 12, 2021 by emma-jean

### What does the term episode mean in meta-learning?

2  Asked on November 12, 2021

### Classification technique to classify categories in two variables when dateset has larger number of numerical variables and few data points

0  Asked on November 12, 2021 by rbeginner

### difference partial dependence and feature weights

1  Asked on November 12, 2021

### Interpreting HRs from stratified cox survival analysis in R

1  Asked on November 12, 2021

### Compare two datasets and whether they agree

2  Asked on November 9, 2021 by jennifer-ruurs

### Handling daily time series data for better accuracy

1  Asked on November 9, 2021 by joy_1379

### Model tuning in the presence of incorrect training labels

1  Asked on November 9, 2021 by astel

### Term for the error in machine learning as a direct result of incorrectly labelled data?

0  Asked on November 9, 2021

### Ask a Question

Get help from others!