I am not sure if they are the same, but something puzzling just happened. My dell precision workstation 2007 has been fine ever since, with many, many power outages over the years. But there is a time a guy pulled the power cable off, and a few days later the PC no longer boot, with loud whooss fan sound at startup. After testing, everything was fine, only the motherboard died, with apparent fried capacitors. And if they are the same, would there be a difference if the PC is plugged to a power strip?
Can anyone please explain? Thank you.
Motherboard electrolytic capacitors don't last forever. They were 13 years old already and degrading so they had just degraded beyond the level that the motherboard will not work any more. The power outage happening few days before motherbord failure is unlikely to have had a significant role.
Answered by Justme on December 19, 2020
The end is the same, power cut, but the transient behaviour (namely voltages) may be quite different.
In a power cut probably voltage would go down, because of the fault causing the power outage and then go to zero, thus having less impact on you. Of course this is the case if the power outage is a "relative" big one.
If the fault on the electrical transmission or distributionn network happens relatively near to you, for instance lighting hitting a power line, then your electrical installation and your PC could suffer from high transient voltage, which are dangerous for electronics.
Now back to the "pulling the cord", this could theoretically cause sparks (and thus high transient voltages.) This could also happen with a normal manual switch which though is normally not used to switch off brutally.
At any rate, the components impacted would be in the power supply unit, as it's there that 12V-5V are "produced" and fed to the motherboard. Also in my opinion the PSU normally protects other components and in worst case fries itself, but overvoltages are attenuated before impacting 12-5V components.
So sorry, no logical explanation for me.
Answered by albertop on December 19, 2020
0 Asked on December 19, 2021 by starstruck88
3 Asked on December 19, 2021 by hex
0 Asked on December 19, 2021 by pokloha
1 Asked on December 19, 2021 by basit-ali
4 Asked on December 17, 2021 by ben-eck
1 Asked on December 17, 2021 by nick-felker
3 Asked on December 17, 2021 by mister-mystre
0 Asked on December 17, 2021 by xakepp35
1 Asked on December 17, 2021 by cit5
2 Asked on December 17, 2021
11 Asked on December 15, 2021 by timonsku
1 Asked on December 15, 2021 by fabin-romo
Get help from others!