What is the best choice in this case, present perfect simple or continuous?

Question

As I buy many records from Australia, I have an Australian friend who collects all the records bought there (I live in France)
Today I received an email from my friend, he wanted to know if he could send them now (as he had a lot of).
I answered "yes" and wrote:

I hope it has not been taking/ has taken too much of your spare time."

What is the best solution? I thought present perfect continuous was better because it is ongoing situation.  May be taken present perfect simple is better as "too much" could be equivalent to a quantity (as in the sentence I have written 6 letters this morning) but I want to emphasize the continuity of this action.

solublefish · Answer

If you want to emphasize the continuity of the action, "has not been taking" is clearly better than "has taken".
If you expect to continue this arrangement, though, you might use
"I hope it is not taking too much of your spare time".
I believe that's the present continuous tense, sometimes called present imperfect. Regardless it offers your acknowledgement of using their time, while subtly indicating that you intend to keep doing so.

Sandip Kumar Mandal · Answer

To talk about actions and situations that have continued up to the present, you may use both the simple present perfect and the present perfect continuous :

I hope it has not taken too much of your spare time.

I hope it has not been taking too much of your spare time.

What is the best choice in this case, present perfect simple or continuous?

2 Answers

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question