TransWikia.com

Why is it "going off this morning" instead of "went off"?

English Language Learners Asked by el Muerto de Mederti on February 22, 2021

I search the definition for ‘What is Alarm Clock?’
and I saw this odd sentence on the Cambridge.org:

Didn’t you hear your alarm clock going off this morning?

Why is the present continuous tense "going off" used instead of "went off"?

2 Answers

Going off is not present continuous. It is not any tense, because it is not a finite verb.

It is a participial clause, modifying the noun phrase your alarm clock, which is the object of hear. It would not be grammatical to use the finite clause went off in that context.

Answered by Colin Fine on February 22, 2021

The person making the statement is describing something which happened in the past. However, the situation being described continued for a while.

Let's say at 9am the speaker is referencing the alarm which started to ring at 7am. The speaker doesn't just mean that at 7am the alarm rang one time.

The speaker means that at 7am it started to ring, and continued to ring, and the owner of the alarm continued to let it ring.

That's the implicit question: "Didn't you hear it ringing? How come you let it ring and didn't get out of bed/didn't turn it off/etc."

It's implying that during the duration of time when the alarm was going off, there should have been some action (which didn't occur).

So it's not just "in the past something happened" but "in the past there was a situation during which something should have happened."

Answered by Binyomin on February 22, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP