TransWikia.com

Prepostions followed by that-clauses

English Language & Usage Asked on May 31, 2021

It’s commonly said that prepositions take declarative clauses without that. However:

  1. The apartment is nice except that the rent is too high.
  1. You can’t always count on it that someone will help.

It seems that Prepositions "except" and "on" are both followed by that-clauses(serving as objects).

In the second example, why should "it" be used and placed between "on" and " that"?

One Answer

I don't entirely agree with the OP's proposition:

prepositions take declarative clauses without that

For example, you can't omit it without rendering 2 ungrammatical:

2'. *You can't always count on (that) someone will help.

Note that 2' is ungrammatical with or without that.

Thus, some prepositions such as on cannot take declarative clauses with or without that.

Having said that, I believe examples of a preposition taking a that-clause as complement are few and far between. Most of these rare examples are not even legitimate examples, if you will.

In 1, for example, the preposition except taking a that-clause as complement can be better explained by ellipsis, as shown below, than by considering it a legitimate example of a preposition taking a that-clause as complement.

  1. The apartment is nice except (for the fact) that the rent is too high.

Answered by JK2 on May 31, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP