TransWikia.com

Present continuous vs present perfect followed by temporal 'for' / 'since'

English Language & Usage Asked on April 9, 2021

In a newspaper I read the following sentence:

  • We are waiting for the past few days with a hope.

Is the grammar correct …

can we use the present continuous with temporal for and since?

English grammar books I have read say we do not.

Please could you clarify.

One Answer

"Do not use present continuous with for or since" is a simplified guideline rather than a rule. The core of the issue here is that whatever time reference you are using must be in agreement with your verbal tense. It just so happens that most usages of for or since provide a time reference that doesn't work with the present continuous, but it isn't impossible as in:

We are waiting for the time being

And colloquially you'll even see things that deviate a bit from standard grammar rules, such as:

We are waiting since noon

If we were being more strict about grammar we could use a number of different tenses depending on the exact context or intention.

Past continuous implies the waiting is now finished:

We were waiting since noon

The present perfect could suggest the waiting has only recently finished or even that it is still ongoing:

We have waited since noon

The present perfect continuous suggests the action is still ongoing and emphasizes the length of it:

We have been waiting since noon

To recap, what matters is for our time reference to be in agreement with the verbal tense used. However, in colloquial situations it is reasonably common to use the present continuous with time references that link to a past moment.

Answered by Lucas Arraes on April 9, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP