Question on prepositions and comparisons

English Language & Usage Asked by Jimmy Bernstein on November 12, 2020

I ran into a grammar book that claims this sentence as incorrect:

Every year, more tourists travel to Disney World than the Louvre

They are saying it needs to be “…to the Louvre”.

Other sources say that second preposition is optional when saying something like

Martha was praised not only for her technique but also (for) her costume.

The only way the first book is correct is if contrasting comparisons are treated differently than comparisons noting a similarity.
Would appreciate any clarifications on who’s right?

One Answer

Based only on the grammar, the sentence is ambiguous. Without a preposition, it can be interpreted as

More tourists travel to Disney World than the Louvre travels to Disney World.

(There's a word or phrase for this type of ambiguity, but I can't remember it -- can someone help me with a comment?).

However, grammar isn't everything. This interpretation makes no sense, since the Louvre can't travel, and even if it could, it's just a single object so no one would compare its number to a large group of people.

Conversely, it's well known that both Disney World and the Louvre are tourist destinations. So the parallel is recognized intuitively, and repeating the preposition "to" is not really necessary, it can be elided and will be understood.

In order to remove all elision, you'd have to repeat "travel" as well, e.g.

Every year, more tourists travel to Disney World than travel to the Louvre.

Answered by Barmar on November 12, 2020

Add your own answers!

Related Questions

What is a good alternative for “stand in”?

1  Asked on March 21, 2021 by ashley-graves


Around Hiram’s barn

4  Asked on March 21, 2021 by jeff-sutro


Sad and Melancholy yet Beautiful

6  Asked on March 21, 2021 by alexander-smith


How to use nouns as a category?

1  Asked on March 20, 2021


Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2022 All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, MenuIva, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP, SolveDir