TransWikia.com

The diagram for showing Future-Perfect-In-Past Tense

English Language & Usage Asked on May 31, 2021

Consider this example:

He said that he would have finished his task before we arrived.

Let’s assign a number to each clause:

  1. He said
  2. that he would have finished his task
  3. before we arrive

If we want to show the time scheme for this sentence in the diagram below, each number would be corresponding to which letter?

enter image description here

One Answer

If you take the "future-in-the-past" meaning of the modal would (which is not its only meaning, but it is the most likely meaning here), then the saying is before the finishing, and according to his intention, the finishing is before the arriving. You cannot tell whether the finishing was actually before the arriving or not; and you cannot tell whether either the finishing or the arriving are in the past.

Like many uses of perfect contructions, the "have" is optional when the temporal relations are clear without it. He said he would finish his task before we arrived is nearly identical in meaning: the only difference is that your sentence sets the temporal focus to our arrival and looks back to his finishing, whereas the form without have doesn't set any particular temporal focus.

Correct answer by Colin Fine on May 31, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP