TransWikia.com

Would it be grammatically correct if I use "having" in the sentence?

English Language & Usage Asked on January 13, 2021

Would it be grammatically correct if I use "having" in the sentence below? I am not sure about using it as it gives a sense of "to possess". Is it correct to use ‘have’ in the continuous tense in this case?

Reference Link: See this website

Sentence:
The phrases "compiled language" and "interpreted language" are nonsensical and are used without having an appropriate notion.

One Answer

The sentence may easily have a context in which the sentiments are true. I therefore set aside any discussion (which in any case belongs elsewhere) of programming.

We are then left with a simplified version: A and B are nonsensical and are used without having an appropriate notion. Not only does having give the feeling of possession but the subject of having is not clear. A and B, being inanimate, cannot have notions, so presumably the subject is those who use the phrases A and B. (Forgive me if subject is not quite the right grammatical term for a noun before a gerund. I, being a physicist, simply regard I as the subject of being).

Among the many possibilities, I therefore suggest ... and are sometimes used without an appropriate notion, ... and are used without appropriate notions, or ... and users' notions of them may be inappropriate. My own taste is for the last one.

Correct answer by Anton on January 13, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP