# Concrete way to teach addition and subtraction of fractions

Mathematics Educators Asked on September 6, 2021

I am teaching 4th-grade kids. The topic is Fraction. Basic understanding of a fraction as a part of the whole and as part of the collection is clear to the kids. Several concrete ways exist to teach this basic concept. But when it comes to fraction addition/subtraction I could not find a way that teaches it concretely.
Of course, teaching fraction addition & subtraction of the form 3/2 + 1/2 is easy. But what about 3/2+ 4/3?
It is where we start talking about the algorithm (using LCM), which makes the matter less intuitive and more abstract which I am trying to avoid in the beginning. I believe all abstract concepts should come after the concrete experience.

So teachers do you have any suggestions?

Another way to represent addition and subtraction of two fractions is by subdividing rectangles both horizontally and vertically.

Say you want to show how to add $$frac{1}{3}$$ and $$frac{2}{5}$$. Draw three equal sized rectangles. Subdivide the first in threes with horizontal lines. Subdivide the second rectangle in fifths with vertical lines. The students probably understand these representations of the fractions already.

The third rectangle is used to represent the sum. Subdivide that rectangle both horizontally and vertically to get fifteens. Now you must ensure that the students understand that this is actually fifteenths, and that they can see how many fifteenths are covered by $$frac{1}{3}$$ and $$frac{2}{5}$$. The first two rectangles should make this obvious to most students.

This representation of the sum of fractions naturally shows how adding thirds and fifths leads to fifteenths. That is, it clearly shows how a common denominator solves the problem. It also shows why the common denominator is found by multiplication.

The representation is not perfect, though. It does not naturally explain the least common denominator, it does not extend to three or more summands without adding dimensions, and it is awkward with improper fractions.

Answered by Roar Stovner on September 6, 2021

Suggestion: Do not bother having students do calculations with two fractions until they can do a comparable operation with a fraction and a whole number.

Example: Before teaching, say, $$frac{3}{2}-frac{4}{3}=__$$, ensure they can answer something like $$4 - frac{1}{5}=__$$. Make sure all students can draw that on a number line and with area diagrams. This is how you ensure that their knowledge of fractions will integrate with their knowledge of whole numbers.

Once students are ready to add and subtract fractions that already have common denominators, ensure they can do so on a number line and with area diagrams and with fraction tiles.

Then, when it comes time to do $$frac{3}{2}+frac{4}{3}=__$$, you can:

1. Put the halves tiles and the thirds tiles together
2. Pretend to be horribly confused by how much that is
3. Estimate it to be a little under 3 wholes
4. Demonstrate how sixths tiles come to the rescue. :)

Answered by WeCanLearnAnything on September 6, 2021

I like the cutting paper approach the best because it is cheap and easy, and it forces students to confront basic fractions by folding/cutting them out. But here’s another thought...

For you to demonstrate: have several clear-plastic, cylindrical cups, each marked off in different fractions of a whole (maybe start with 1/2’s, 1/3’s, 1/4’s, 1/6’s, 1/8’s, 1/10’s and 1/12’s). Have another larger cylinder marked off in whole numbers of the smaller cups.

Write the problem $$frac{3}{2} + frac{4}{3}$$ and have students make a guess/estimate, and then use the 1/2 and 1/3 cups to fill up with colored liquid or rice (which is why you will demonstrate this). Add the liquid to the large cylinder to see that “yeah, it’s between 2 and 3”, as the students should have guessed. Then work backward, pouring away whole numbers worth of smaller cups until you have less than a whole cup left In the large cylinder. Now try the smaller cups one-by-one until you find one in which the remaining liquid fills up to a marker line. Finally, declare the answer as the mixed number $$2 frac{5}{6}$$.

I might do this with two nice examples (where I have the appropriately-marked cups) and then try the first one out again, but pour each of the original fractions into the 1/6’s cup before adding them together in the large cylinder. Lots of things you could do with these.

Answered by Nick C on September 6, 2021

Use a piece of paper as your whole. To teach $$3/2 + 4/3$$ do the following.

1. Give each child/group of children 6 pieces of paper.
2. One piece of paper should be left as a whole - the students can write 1 whole on the paper.
3. Have the students fold 2 of the pieces in half lengthwise, label each half as $$1/2$$, and cut out the halves.
4. Have the students fold 2 pieces of papers in thirds widthwise, label each third as $$1/3$$ and cut out the thirds.
5. Have the students take $$3/2$$ and $$4/3$$ and try to add them. You will have 2 wholes and $$1/2$$ and $$1/3$$ Discuss what to do with the leftover pieces...
6. Next take the last piece of paper and fold in sixths by folding in half lengthwise and in thirds widthwise. Label each piece $$1/6$$ and cut out the pieces.
7. Put the some of the sixths from part 6 on the leftover pieces in part 5 to show that $$1/2=3/6$$ and $$1/3 = 2/6$$. Together they make $$5/6$$

Hope this works for you.

Answered by Amy B on September 6, 2021

Use a language approach.

This is not meant to be a snide remark; I came across a particular TED talk a while ago that illustrated how math is just another language and we must first learn the proper syntax.

Of course, we know that adding fractions require the use of common denominators, so I would first introduce the topic of equivalent fractions. If the concept of common denominators is new to the student, perhaps using something concrete like denominations of coins can help bridge that gap.

Answered by Andrew Chin on September 6, 2021

## Related Questions

### What are the best practices for giving online tests?

6  Asked on September 6, 2021

### How to get better at proofs

6  Asked on September 5, 2021 by occhima

### Logic and proofs in secondary school

2  Asked on September 5, 2021 by rusty-core

### Is There Such Thing as Reaching Half a Standard?

0  Asked on September 5, 2021 by w-g

### How to naturally encounter the properties of identity, commutativity, associativity, and distributivity (to define rings)?

4  Asked on September 5, 2021 by d-r

### Reference Request: Suitability of a text and corresponding video lecture series request for “Matroid Theory”

1  Asked on September 5, 2021

### Do you mention the continuity and the differentiability of the empty function

2  Asked on September 5, 2021

### Would it make sense for math courses to be pass/fail?

2  Asked on September 5, 2021 by lex_i

### What is “mastery” in a mathematical topic?

2  Asked on September 5, 2021

### What is a good place for teachers to share self-created content?

1  Asked on September 5, 2021 by ritesh-singh

### Good resources on matrix equations

2  Asked on September 5, 2021 by razivo

### How much more skilled in the topic should you be in order to teach the topic?

2  Asked on September 5, 2021

### How do I learn advanced mathematics without forgetting?

8  Asked on September 5, 2021 by user14243

### Ramanujan results for middle school?

1  Asked on September 5, 2021

### At what age are most children able to convert between rational fractions and decimals?

4  Asked on September 5, 2021

### How can teachers warn students about common mistakes without causing the student to make the mistake?

7  Asked on September 5, 2021 by user13544

### Create a math quiz with LaTex by randomly choosing questions from a bank

3  Asked on January 19, 2021

### Research for Video Length for Math Videos

1  Asked on January 14, 2021 by cab

### Statistics, for the mathematically rigorous

4  Asked on January 13, 2021 by john-clever