For i.i.d random variables $X$ and $Y$, is $E[X mid sigma(X+Y)] = frac{X+Y}{2}$?

Let $$X$$ and $$Y$$ be i.i.d. random variables; we want to calculate the conditional expectation with respect to the $$sigma$$-algebra generated by $$X+Y$$:

$$E [X mid sigma(X+Y)]$$

Now, generally for random variables $$X, Y in L^1$$, if
$$E[X1_A(X)1_B(Y)] = E[Y1_A(Y)1_B(X)] quad (A, B in mathcal{B}(mathbb{R}))$$

then$$E[X1_C(X+Y)] = E[Y1_C(X+Y)] quad (C in mathcal{B}(mathbb{R}))$$

So here is my solution so far: the above holds for i.i.d. random variables $$X, Y$$, so
$$E[X mid sigma(X+Y)] = E[Y mid sigma(X+Y)]$$, and then we have
$$E[X mid sigma(X + Y) ] = frac{1}{2} E[X + Y mid sigma(X + Y) ] = frac{X+Y}{2}$$

I feel like I am missing something here…

Mathematics Asked on December 27, 2020

The third line in your proof is proved rigorously as follows: $$E[X1_C(X+Y)]=int x1_{{(x,y): x+y in C }} dF_{X,Y}(x,y).$$ Applying the transformation $$(x,y)to (y,x)$$ and noting that $$F_{X,Y}=F_{Y,X}$$ we see that $$int x1_{{(x,y): x+y in C }} dF_{X,Y}(x,y) =int y1_{{(x,y): x+y in C }} dF_{X,Y}(x,y)$$. Hence $$E[Y1_C(X+Y)]=E[X1_C(X+Y)]$$.

Correct answer by Kavi Rama Murthy on December 27, 2020

Related Questions

For each of the following sets A, B prove or disprove whether A ⊆ B and B ⊆ A

1  Asked on February 7, 2021

Proofing Metropolis Hastings

0  Asked on February 7, 2021 by nestroy

How to solve this limit $lim_{nto infty}(frac{2^n}{n^k})$?

4  Asked on February 7, 2021

Is a ring homomorphism surjective if the restriction to the group of units is surjective?

1  Asked on February 7, 2021 by barry-allen

$Var(X_1 X_2)=Var(X_1) Var(X_2)$

2  Asked on February 7, 2021

Principal component analysis for ‘signal extraction’

0  Asked on February 7, 2021 by mat-p

Show that ${a log n }$ is not equidistributed for any $a$

1  Asked on February 7, 2021 by dark_knight

Monotone Convergence Property $iff$ Order Completeness in an arbitrary ordered field.

1  Asked on February 6, 2021

The product of the ages of someone’s children

2  Asked on February 6, 2021 by rathal

A committee of m members is to be chosen from a population of n students. What is your probability of being chosen?

1  Asked on February 6, 2021 by joseph-bungabong

Prove by induction floor and ceiling

1  Asked on February 6, 2021 by user836026

$a,b,c,d$ are complex numbers corresponding to points $A,B,C,D$ lying on a circle with origin as center,and chord $AB⟂CD$. Find $ab+cd$

3  Asked on February 6, 2021 by maven

Let, $N,K,N’,K’$ be groups and $Ncong N’,Kcong K’$. Does $Nrtimes Kcong N’rtimes K’$?

0  Asked on February 6, 2021 by deltaepsilon

Integrate $2x(2x-3)^frac{1}{2} dx$.

5  Asked on February 5, 2021 by pretending-to-be-a-calculator

Dimensionality theorem irreps finite dimensional algebra

1  Asked on February 5, 2021 by gert

On approximating the distribution of the distance between two random points on an $n$-sphere

1  Asked on February 5, 2021 by let101

Rule of inference. Is the argument valid?

2  Asked on February 5, 2021 by blue

Relation between norm and variance of a random vector

1  Asked on February 4, 2021

limit superior of union and intersection of sets.

1  Asked on February 4, 2021