TransWikia.com

How to evaluate sequence of operations on an object?

Mathematics Asked by user1787812 on December 29, 2021

Example 1

Rational tangle dance mentioned here with operations:

  • T(tangle)

  • R(rotate)

For example, sequence of operations $TTRTT$ is considered as

$T^2 cdot R cdot T^2$

but not

$2T + R + 2T$

mathematically. why?


Example 2

Symmetries of polygon shown here, with operations:

  • R(rotation)

  • F(Flip)

For example, $RFFRFFF$ is considered as

$R cdot F^2 cdot R cdot F^3$

but not

$R +2F + R + 3F$

mathematically, why?


Example 3

Flipping a coin

The number of possible outcomes of each coin flip is 2 (either heads or tails.) So the probability of either a heads or a tails is 1/2. This make sense to me.

But, the number of possible outcomes of several independent events is the product of the number of possible outcomes of each event individually. Yet to understand.

The number of combinations that 3 coin flips will give 2 x 2 x 2 = 8 but not 2 + 2 + 2 = 6, why?


Am assuming,

example 1 & 2 are from non-arithmetic world

and

example 3 is from arithmetic world(Number theory).


How addition operation is different from multiplication in arithmetic & non-arithmetic world?

One Answer

Your first two examples are very different from the third example in more ways than just saying that the third is an arithmetic question while the first two are not.

In the first two examples you are asking about conventions regarding notation. Given two functions $f$ and $g$ on a set $X$, you are asking why the composition $fcirc fcirc g$ is denoted $f^2g$ rather than $2f+g$. But again, these are questions of notation. If I use $f^2g$ to denote $fcirc fcirc g$, I am not at all suggesting that there is some kind of multiplication of numbers involved. Similarly, if I were to use $2f+g$ to denote this function instead then, again, this does not mean that addition of numbers is involved. I am simply choosing to denote $fcirc fcirc g$ in a different way.

So your question is: Why is the notation $f^2g$ more common than $2f+g$? The answer is that people often use the addition symbol $+$ to denote binary operations that are commutative: $x+y=y+x$ for all objects $x$ and $y$. Since composition of functions is not commutative, people usually don't use the addition symbol in this way. On the flip side, people do use the multiplicative notation for general operations that are not necessarily commutative. So this is why $f^2g$ is more likely to be used than $2f+g$.

Now, your third question is not a notation question. It is a mathematical question that is asking about something very different from the first two questions. You are asking why the number of outcomes of flipping 3 coins is 8 and not 6. For one thing, you can count them:

HHH
HHT
HTH
HTT
THH
THT
TTH
TTT

So perhaps the real question is the following. Suppose we have a task that can be broken into two steps. Say there are $m$ ways to do step 1, and $n$ ways to do step $2$. Why is the total number of ways to do the whole task $mn$ and not $m+n$? This question is equivalent to the following:

Suppose $|A|=m$ and $|B|=n$. Then why is $|Atimes B|=mn$ and not $m+n$?

This is an equivalent question because I can think of $A$ as the set of ways to do step $1$ and $B$ as the set of ways to do step 2. So $Atimes B$ is the set of ways to do the whole task since I can represent doing the whole task as an ordered pair $(a,b)$ where $a$ comes from $A$ and $b$ comes from $B$.

The proof that $|Atimes B|=mn$ is not too hard. Write $Atimes B=bigcup_{ain A}X_a$ where $X_a={(a,b):bin B}$. If $aneq a'$ then $X_{a}cap X_{a'} = emptyset$. So $|Atimes B|=sum_{ain A}|X_{a}|$. For any $ain A$, there is a clear bijection between $X_{a}$ and $B$ in which one sends $(a,b)$ to $b$. So $|X_{a}|=|B|$ for all $ain A$. So $|Atimes B|=sum_{ain A}|B|=|A|cdot |B|=mn$.

Your example with coins had three steps instead of two, but you can generalize to any number of steps using induction. In combinatorics, this is called the "multiplication principle". See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rule_of_product

Answered by halrankard on December 29, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP