TransWikia.com

Rolling Dice Game, Probability of Ending on an Even Roll

Mathematics Asked by IanFromWashington on January 3, 2022

The game is described as follows. $A$ and $B$ take turns rolling a fair six sided die. Say $A$ rolls first. Then if $A$ rolls {1,2} they win. If not, then $B$ rolls. If $B$ rolls {3,4,5,6} then they win. This process repeats until $A$ or $B$ wins, and the game stops.

What is the probability that the game ends on an even turn when $A$ rolls first?

Now the book gives the answer as $frac{4}{7}$, however, when try to calculate I end up with $frac{2}{11}$.

Below is my work:

To calculate this probability, we decompose the event into two disjoint events, (a) the event where $A$ wins on an even roll, and (b) the event where $B$ wins on an even roll.

(a) Now, the probability $A$ wins can be calculated as follows
begin{align*}
biggr(frac{2}{3} cdot frac{1}{3}biggr)biggr(frac{1}{3}biggr) + biggr(frac{2}{3} cdot frac{1}{3}biggr)biggr(frac{2}{3} cdot frac{1}{3}biggr)biggr(frac{2}{3} cdot frac{1}{3}biggr)biggr(frac{1}{3}biggr) + dots = sum_{k=0}^infty biggr(frac{2}{9}biggr)^{2k+1}frac{1}{3}\
= sum_{k=0}^infty frac{2}{27}biggr(frac{2}{9}biggr)^{2k} = sum_{k=0}^infty frac{2}{27}biggr(frac{4}{81}biggr)^k = frac{2}{27}cdot frac{1}{1- frac{4}{81}} = frac{6}{77}.
end{align*}

(b) Similarly we calculate the probability $B$ wins on an even roll as
begin{align*}
biggr(frac{2}{3} cdot frac{1}{3}biggr)biggr(frac{2}{3}cdot frac{2}{3}biggr) + biggr(frac{2}{3} cdot frac{1}{3}biggr)biggr(frac{2}{3} cdot frac{1}{3}biggr)biggr(frac{2}{3} cdot frac{1}{3}biggr)biggr(frac{2}{3}cdotfrac{2}{3}biggr) + dots = sum_{k=0}^infty biggr(frac{2}{9}biggr)^{2k+1}frac{4}{9}\
= sum_{k=0}^infty frac{8}{81}biggr(frac{2}{9}biggr)^{2k} = sum_{k=0}^infty frac{8}{81}biggr(frac{4}{81}biggr)^k = frac{8}{81}cdot frac{1}{1- frac{4}{81}} = frac{8}{77}.
end{align*}

Therefore, it follows that the probability of the game ending on an even number of rolls is
begin{equation*}
frac{6}{77} + frac{8}{77} = frac{2}{11}.
end{equation*}

Am I missing something?

4 Answers

Working under the assumption that the intended interpretation of the question was merely asking the probability that $B$ wins (i.e. distinguishing between the term "rounds" as iterating whenever A has a turn and "turns" iterating whenever either A or B has a turn) two other approaches have already been written. Here I will include yet another approach:

Consider the final round, that is a roll of $A$ followed by a roll of $B$, where we allow $B$ to roll even in the event that $A$ has already won despite the roll not influencing the final result of the game.

Ordinarily there are $6times 6 = 36$ equally likely results for a round. Here, we condition on the fact that it is the last round, implying that it was not the case that both players missed their respective targets. This gives $6times 6 - 4times 2 = 28$ equally likely possible final rounds.

Of these, $4times 4 = 16$ of them end with $A$ missing their target and $B$ hitting theirs.

The probability of $B$ winning the game is then: $$dfrac{16}{28} = dfrac{4}{7}$$

Answered by JMoravitz on January 3, 2022

Thanks to the comment of @JMoravitz I realized my mistake. I was interpreting turns as the rolls $A$ AND $B$, as in ${A_1,B_1}, {A_2,B_2}, dots$. In reality the question is merely asking what the probability of $B$ winning if $A$ rolls first.

The work is as follows: We calculate the probability of $B$ winning. Denote the probability of $B$ winning on their $i$th roll as $S_i$. Now, the probabilities of $B$ winning on her first roll, second roll, third roll, etc., are as follows: begin{equation*} P(S_1) = biggr(frac{2}{3}biggr)biggr(frac{2}{3}biggr), quad P(S_2) = biggr(frac{2}{3}biggr)biggr(frac{1}{3}biggr)biggr(frac{2}{3}biggr)biggr(frac{2}{3}biggr), quad P(S_3) = biggr(biggr(frac{2}{3}biggr)biggr(frac{1}{3}biggr)biggr)^2biggr(frac{2}{3}biggr)biggr(frac{2}{3}biggr), dots end{equation*} It then follows that in general that $displaystyle P(S_i) = biggr(frac{2}{9}biggr)^{i-1} biggr(frac{4}{9}biggr).$ Thus, it follows that the probability of $B$ winning is calculated as begin{equation*} P(S) = Pbiggr(bigcup_{i=1}^infty S_ibiggr) = sum_{i=1}^infty P(S_i) = sum_{i=1}^infty biggr(frac{2}{9}biggr)^{i-1} biggr(frac{4}{9}biggr) = frac{4}{9} sum_{i=1}^infty biggr(frac{2}{9}biggr)^{i-1} = frac{4}{9} cdot frac{9}{7} = frac{4}{7}. end{equation*}

Answered by IanFromWashington on January 3, 2022

The problem is not clear as stated.

Interpretation $#1$: If you interpret it as "find the probability that the game end in an evenly numbered round" you can reason recursively.

Let $P$ denote the answer. The probability that the game ends in the first round is $frac 26+frac 46times frac 46=frac 79$. If you don't end in the first round, the probability is now $1-P$. Thus $$P=frac 79times 0 +frac 29times (1-P)implies boxed{P=frac 2{11}}$$

as in your solution.

Interpretation $#2$: If the problem meant "find the probability that $B$ wins given that $A$ starts" that too can be solved recursively. Let $Psi$ denote that answer and let $Phi$ be the probability that $B$ wins given that $B$ starts. Then $$Psi=frac 46times Phi$$ and $$Phi=frac 46 +frac 26times Psi$$ This system is easily solved and yields $$boxed {Psi=frac 47}$$ as desired.

Answered by lulu on January 3, 2022

The answer = 1/2

The game has to end by either A winning or B winning

Let's say A wins. He is just as likely to roll a 1 or a 2 on the last roll. Therefore in a game that A wins, probability of an even roll ending the game is 1/2, as 1(odd) and 2(even) are equally likely.

Let's say B wins. He is just as likely to roll a 3/4/5/6 on the last roll. Therefore in a game that B wins, probability of an even roll ending the game is 1/2, as 4 and 6 are favourable outcomes.

P.S. I have assumed that "ending on an even roll" as written in the title means the die outputs an even number. I agree that while the body of the question seems to suggest an even turn, this seems like the correct interpretation to me.

Answered by user635640 on January 3, 2022

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP