What is the probability that balls left are white?

Mathematics Asked by abhishek on September 18, 2020

From a bag containing $$b$$ black balls and $$a$$ white balls, balls are successively drawn without replacement until only those of the same colour are left. What is the probability that balls left are white?

the favourable event occurs when the balls drawn consist of

1. $$0$$ white and $$b$$ black balls
2. $$1$$ white and $$b$$ black balls
3. $$2$$ white and $$b$$ black balls

$$spacespacespace$$:
$$spacespacespacea$$. $$a-1$$ white and $$b$$ black balls

the last ball drawn cannot be white. it has to be black.

the probability of drawing $$i$$ white and $$b$$ black balls, successively without replacement from a bag containing $$b$$ black balls and $$a$$ white balls, such that the last ball drawn is black is $$p_i = frac{binom{a}{i}binom{b}{1}binom{b-1}{b-1}(b-1+i)!}{binom{a+b}{b+i}(b+i)!} = frac{frac{a!}{(a-i)!i!} cdot b cdot 1 cdot (b-1+i)!}{frac{(a+b)!}{(b+i)!(a-i)!}(b+i)!} = frac{a! cdot b cdot (b-1+i)!}{(a+b)! cdot i!}$$

$$text{the probability that the balls left are white } = sum_{i=0}^{a-1}p_i = frac{a! cdot b}{(a+b)!}sum_{i=0}^{a-1}frac{(b-1+i)!}{i!}$$

the given answer is $$frac{a}{a+b}$$

my question is:

is what I have done correct? if yes, how do I proceed further? if no, then what is wrong in my approach?

while I know that there is a very elegant proof for this question, I am curious as to why a very simple approach to solving this question is not working.

Lets take two cases-

1. where all ball left are white
2. where all balls left are black

Case 1:

You can take out all the black balls at one go and then successively pick out a white ball one by one. The number of ways in which you can do this such that the bag doesn't get emptied will be 'a'(This works since all the white balls are identical.).

Case 2:

Similarly, you can take out all the white balls at one go and then successively pick out a black ball one by one. The number of ways in which you can do this such that the bag doesn't get emptied will be 'b'(This works since all the black balls are identical.).

So the probablity will be simply $$a/(a+b)$$

Answered by Abhirup Adhikary on September 18, 2020

Related Questions

How to prove that $-|z| le Re (z) le |z|$ and $-|z| le Im (z) le |z|$?

2  Asked on November 12, 2021

Does $g(v_n) longrightarrow g(0)$ for all $v_n text{s.t.} ||v_{n+1}|| leq ||v_n||$ imply $g$ continuos at $0$?

2  Asked on November 12, 2021 by a_student

Your favorite way to think of $k[x_1,ldots,x_n]$ modulo some graded ideal?

0  Asked on November 12, 2021

Why are the probability and mean number of edges between two nodes in a network equal for large networks?

1  Asked on November 12, 2021

Geometric proof for the half angle tangent

3  Asked on November 12, 2021 by brazilian_student

What are the relations between eigenvectors of $A$ and its adjoint $A^*$?

3  Asked on November 12, 2021 by user66906

Skyscrapers sheaf’s global sections

2  Asked on November 12, 2021 by abramo

Constructibility of the 17-gon

2  Asked on November 12, 2021

Building palisade with Lego bricks

1  Asked on November 12, 2021

Evaluating the integral $int^{infty}_{-infty} frac{dx}{x^4-2cos(2theta)x^2 +1}$

2  Asked on November 12, 2021 by user793781

Ideals in a UFD

1  Asked on November 12, 2021

The relationship between LCTVS and projective limit of a projective family of norm spaces.

1  Asked on November 12, 2021

Matrix-vector multiplication/cross product problem

1  Asked on November 12, 2021 by kurt-muster

Proving a self independent random variable can get only one value

1  Asked on November 12, 2021 by override

Regular Expression describing language accepted by Finite State Automata

1  Asked on November 12, 2021 by awu

Solving this DE

1  Asked on November 12, 2021

Driven harmonic oscillator: Why does the phase of the driver have such a big impact on the solution?

1  Asked on November 12, 2021

Bijection of a Generalised Cartesian Product

1  Asked on November 12, 2021

Prove that $a ⊈ {a}$, where $a$ is non-empty

1  Asked on November 12, 2021 by galaxylokka

Use linearisation of a certain function to approximate $sqrt[3]{30}$

3  Asked on November 12, 2021