# Why does every oscillating sequence diverge?

Mathematics Asked by user13985 on November 3, 2020

Is this statement true?

$$bftext{Every oscillating sequence diverges.}$$

My thoughts: $$bf{False}$$. $$s_n = (-1)^n$$ does not converge. But it’s bounded, therefore, not divergent either. Divergent means diverging to $$-infty$$ or $$+ infty$$, yes?

Solution key: $$bf{True}$$. If a sequence oscillates, then its limit inferior and limit superior are unequal. If follows that it cannot converge, for if it converged all its subsequences would converge to the same limit.

Three other places discussing oscillating convergence:

1. This website says: "Oscillating sequences are not convergent or
divergent. Such as 1, 0, 3, 0, 5, 0, 7,…" I agree.

2. This SE post says: "Diverge means doesn’t converge." But, I
think it can be neither?

3. This SE post says: "$$sin xe^{-x}$$ is oscillating and
convergent." I agree.

So, is the solution key correct? Who’s right here?

This depends on your definition of oscillation of sequences.According to the Wikipedia page here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oscillation_(mathematics)#Oscillation_of_a_sequence, the oscillation is zero if and only if the sequence converges. So the answer key is correct because the difference between limit superior and the limit inferior is non-zero and hence the oscillation is non-zero, and so the sequence does not converge.

Answered by Poorwelsh on November 3, 2020

In the usual definitions that I have picked up from various instructors and textbooks, "this sequence diverges" just means "this sequence doesn't converge". You could self-consistently define things the other way, but this is unusual in my experience.

By contrast, "this sequence oscillates" is usually not rigorously defined. Thus when we somewhat casually say "this sequence doesn't converge because it oscillates forever" we really mean "this sequence doesn't converge because it oscillates with an amplitude bounded away from zero forever". With no formal definition setting the context, I would probably say that $$frac{(-1)^n}{n}$$ both oscillates and converges.

Answered by Ian on November 3, 2020

You have to be very precise with your definitions. Generally, we call a sequence divergent if it does not converge. This means that convergent and divergent are each other's opposite.

As far as I know, there is no accepted definition for oscillating sequence.

The sequence $$(-1)^n$$ diverges, because it does not converge, while the sequence $$frac{(-1)^n}{n}$$ converges to zero. Depending on the precise definition, you may or may not call the latter sequence oscillating, so you have to consult your textbook there.

Answered by Wizact on November 3, 2020

## Related Questions

### How to prove that there is not a monomorphism from Klein 4-group to $Z_6$(or a epimorphism from $Z_6$ to $V_4$)?

1  Asked on January 25, 2021 by tota

### Homomorphisms between fields are injective.

4  Asked on January 25, 2021

### We have an integer n. We have n boxes where each box contains a non-negative amount of balls. Find all the permutations which satisfy some criteria

1  Asked on January 25, 2021 by michael-blane

### Approximation of the sum of a series $S(t)=-frac{2}{pi t} cos(frac{pi t}{2}) sum_{m odd}^{infty}frac{m^2alpha_m}{t^2-m^2}$ as $tto +infty$

0  Asked on January 25, 2021 by yolbarsop

### Homogenous space of elliptic curve E/$Bbb Q$

1  Asked on January 25, 2021 by bellow

### On the functional square root of $x^2+1$

9  Asked on January 25, 2021 by user1551

### Is there a simple way to find all the solutions of $x_1 + x_2 + dots + x_k + dots + x_K = N$ when $x_k$s and $N$ are all non-negative integers?

2  Asked on January 25, 2021 by cardinal

### Minimizing the Schatten 1-norm over symmetric matrices.

2  Asked on January 25, 2021 by gene

### The frontier of a set

1  Asked on January 25, 2021 by gal-ben-ayun

### express a matrix using Kronecker product

0  Asked on January 25, 2021 by jyothi-jain

### Approximating multiples of reals with integers

1  Asked on January 25, 2021

### How is this sentence written correctly in maths? (sets)

0  Asked on January 25, 2021 by eyesima

### Let $n$ be an integer. If the tens digit of $n^2$ is 7, what is the units digit of $n^2$?

6  Asked on January 24, 2021 by user713999

### Partitioning $mathbb{R}$ for given functions.

0  Asked on January 24, 2021

### How to count the number of symmetries of a 3-d object?

1  Asked on January 24, 2021

### Is checking really needed?

3  Asked on January 24, 2021 by 1b3b

### Struggling to understand proof, there is no simple group of order $525$

1  Asked on January 24, 2021 by scott-frazier

### prove the following compact result about $GL(n,mathbb{R})$

1  Asked on January 24, 2021

### i need to proove that An∪B→A∪B

1  Asked on January 24, 2021 by methodcl

### How can I show that $T(omega) = T(overline{omega})$ when $X_{t}(omega)=X_{t}(overline{omega})$ for all $t in [0,T(omega)]cap [0,infty)$

1  Asked on January 24, 2021 by minathuma