# A G-delta-sigma that is not F-sigma?

MathOverflow Asked by Julián Aguirre on August 20, 2020

A subset of $$mathbb{R}^n$$ is

• $$G_delta$$ if it is the intersection
of countably many open sets
• $$F_sigma$$ if it is the union of countably many closed sets
• $$G_{deltasigma}$$ if it is the union
of countably many $$G_delta$$‘s

This process gives rise to the Borel hierarchy.

Since all closed sets are $$G_delta$$, all $$F_sigma$$ are $$G_{deltasigma}$$. What is an explicit example of a $$G_{deltasigma}$$ that is not $$F_sigma$$?

Any dense $G_{delta}$ with empty interior is of II Baire category, and cannot be $F_sigma$ by the Baire theorem (and of course it is in particular a $G_{deltasigma}$).

Correct answer by Pietro Majer on August 20, 2020

I just stumbled upon this old question, and thought I would add a simple and natural example, which is $$G_{delta sigma}$$ but neither $$G_{delta}$$ nor $$F_{sigma}$$.

Consider $$fcolon mathbb{C}tomathbb{C}; zmapsto e^z$$, and its iterates $$f^n(z) = underbrace{f(f(dots f(z)dots))}_{text{n times}}=e^{e^{cdot^{cdot^{cdot^{e^z}}}}}.$$ Consider the set $$X := {zinmathbb{C}colon f^n(z)nottoinfty}$$ and its subset $$X_0 := {zinmathbb{C}colon {f^n(z)colon ngeq 0} text{ is dense in mathbb{C}}}.$$

It follows from the definitions that $$X_0$$ is a $$G_{delta}$$ and $$X$$ is a $$G_{delta sigma}$$. It is well-known that $$X_0$$ is dense in $$mathbb{C}$$, as is the complement $$I(f) = mathbb{C}setminus X$$. (For an elementary proof, see The exponential map is chaotic, Amer. Math. Monthly 2017, arxiv:1408.1129.)

So $$X_0$$ contains a dense $$G_{delta}$$, and can therefore not be $$F_{sigma}$$, as noted by Pietro Majer.

That $$X$$ is not $$G_{delta}$$ follows from the fact that $$I(f)$$ is not $$F_{sigma}$$. (Escaping sets are not sigma-compact, arxiv:2006.16946.)

(More generally, for any transcendental entire function, the set of non-escaping points is a $$G_{delta sigma}$$ but neither $$G_{delta}$$ nor $$F_{sigma}$$.)

Answered by Lasse Rempe-Gillen on August 20, 2020

There is a class of (natural?) examples here.

Answered by Ashutosh on August 20, 2020

Here are some examples from recursion theory which are boldface $mathbf{Pi^0_3}$ (the first is $Pi^0_3(emptyset')$ and the others are lightface $Pi^0_3$) but not boldface $mathbf{Sigma^0_3}$:

The collection of weakly-2-random reals;

The collection of Schnorr random reals;

The collection of computably random reals.

References:

1. The Arithmetical Complexity of Dimension and Randomness. John M. Hitchcock, Jack H. Lutz, and Sebastiaan A. Terwijn. ACM Transactions on Computational Logic, 2007.

2. Descriptive set theoretical complexity of randomness notions. Liang Yu. To appear.

Answered by 喻 良 on August 20, 2020

You want a $$Sigma^0_3$$ set which is not $$Pi^0_3$$. The canonical answer is a "universal $$Sigma^0_3$$ set". You can find these concepts in books on Descriptive Set Theory (such as the one by Moschovakis or the one by Kechris).

A specific example: Let $$N_{10}$$ be the set of normal numbers (each digit appears with the right asymptotic frequency in the decimal expansion). Then $$N_{10}$$ is a $$Pi^0_3$$ set which as complicated as $$Pi^0_3$$ sets get (in particular: every $$Pi^0_3$$ set is a continuous preimage of it). In particular, it is not $$Sigma^0_3$$. So the complement of $$N_{10}$$ is what you want.

References:

1. Haseo Ki and Tom Linton, "Normal numbers and subsets of $$mathbb N$$ with given densities", Fundamenta Math (1994). MR1273694

2. Goldstern, "Complexity of uniform distribution", Mathematica Slovaca (1994). MR1338422

Answered by Goldstern on August 20, 2020

## Related Questions

### Does the following sum converge?

1  Asked on December 21, 2021 by ryan-chen

### Is a homotopy sphere with maximum Morse perfection actually diffeomorphic to a standard sphere?

0  Asked on December 21, 2021 by fredy

### Differential birational equivalence

0  Asked on December 20, 2021

### Calculating $n$-dimensional hypervolumes ($n sim 50$), for example

1  Asked on December 20, 2021 by luka-klini

### Definition of a system of recurrent events

1  Asked on December 20, 2021 by rob-arthan

### Regularity of a conformal map

2  Asked on December 20, 2021 by amorfati

### Is there a standard definition of weak form of a nonlinear PDE?

1  Asked on December 20, 2021

### Is there an algebraic version of Darboux’s theorem?

1  Asked on December 20, 2021

### The strength of “There are no $Pi^1_1$-pseudofinite sets”

1  Asked on December 20, 2021

### Are groups with the Haagerup property hyperlinear?

1  Asked on December 18, 2021 by maowao

### Proof of second incompleteness theorem for Set theory without Arithmetization of Syntax

0  Asked on December 18, 2021

### Characterization of effective descent morphism

0  Asked on December 18, 2021 by kind-bubble

### Analogue of decay of Fourier coefficients of a smooth function on $mathbb{S}^1$

2  Asked on December 18, 2021

### Strong Data Processing Inequality for capped channels

1  Asked on December 18, 2021 by thomas-dybdahl-ahle

### lattice suprema vs pointwise suprema

2  Asked on December 18, 2021 by giuliosky

### In infinite dimensions, is it possible that convergence of distances to a sequence always implies convergence of that sequence?

2  Asked on December 18, 2021

### Are those distributional solutions that are functions, the same as weak solutions?

0  Asked on December 18, 2021

### Ability to have function sequence converging to zero at some points

1  Asked on December 16, 2021 by mathcounterexamples-net

### Curious anti-commutative ring

1  Asked on December 16, 2021 by robert-bruner

### Minkowski (box-counting) dimension of generalized Cantor set

0  Asked on December 16, 2021