Broken string fixed but it still sounds off

Music: Practice & Theory Asked by mehrdad on October 18, 2020

My fourth string broke a few days back, and fortunately (?) the breakage was near the bridge so I was able to fix it without having to buy a new one. The thing is it’s been almost a week and even though my fourth string is tuned spot on, it doesn’t sound right. Technically it is a D, but it doesn’t sound like a classical-guitar D, it is sharper as if it’s acoustic.
I tried an old string and I got the same results. Any help?

3 Answers

It's a wound string on a classical guitar, by the clues. There's most likely a problem either with the winding, or the core - or both, that isn't easy to find, visually. As a stop gap, with no spare (why not?), maybe it's better than not having a D string at all, but the sensible thing to do is replace with a new one.

If that new one makes the others - especially the bottom three - sound dull, then replace all three. If the top three sound o.k, they won't need changing. Run a finger along their lengths, under the strings. Any lack of smoothness there is saying 'replace me too'.

Answered by Tim on October 18, 2020

To complete on @LaurencePayne 's answer: from the info you give I would assume you are talking about a classical guitar (edit: I now see the tags…), which strings are not ball-ended. If not, you would not have been able to put it back.

If that is correct, you took some length from the peg to compensate the amount you lost. Doing so, you brought some "fresh" string in the playing area where it actually vibrates. By "fresh" I mean unoxided, it does not mean that this part of the string is actually "like new": if the pegs are small, it is likely that the string has been affected by being wrapped around it.

Anyway, the fact is that you now have a string with two different resonating characteristic: the already played part, and the part you brought from the peg. This will surely sound different (how exactly, hard to say) than the previous string.

In all cases, if the string was worn to the point of breaking (and it's not even the treble E!) that it might be worth changing it, like Laurence said (or even the whole set for a more coherent sound, like @Tetsujin said ;) )!

Answered by Tom on October 18, 2020

Does "sharper as if it's acoustic" mean something about the tone-colour? I guess this is an electric guitar then? Are the pickup poles individually adjustable? Perhaps the string's just worn out. A worn-out string typically sounds duller rather than 'sharper' though.

Go on, lay out for a new string!

Answered by Laurence Payne on October 18, 2020

Add your own answers!

Related Questions

Does a diatonic scale contain more than 7 pitches?

4  Asked on October 25, 2021 by wcobalt


Have MIDI file. Want Audio. Don’t know how

5  Asked on October 25, 2021 by michael-m-k


Nancarrow piano studies collections: why are they ordered that way?

2  Asked on October 25, 2021 by noah-schweber


Mystery bowing notation

2  Asked on October 25, 2021 by tris-forster


Name for minor scale with flat fifth

5  Asked on October 25, 2021


Do I need a practice pad?

2  Asked on October 25, 2021 by rizan


How to conduct a fermata over a rest?

1  Asked on October 25, 2021 by ize


Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2022 All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, MenuIva, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP