# Analogies between electrostatics and steady state heat equation?

Physics Asked on January 4, 2022

In electrostatics we have

$$nabla cdot E = rho/varepsilon$$
and using the divergence theorem we get

$$int_{partialOmega} E cdot hat{n} dS = int_Omega rho/varepsilon dV.$$

This states that the electric flux out of the domain $Omega$ is equal to the total charge inside $Omega$. I think of this as the total ‘force’ that can be felt (by a charge) pushing outwards at the boundary.

Can the same thought process by applied to the steady state heat equation (I have no experience with thermodynamics). We have

$$nabla cdot (nabla T) = f$$
and using the divergence theorem we get

$$int_{partialOmega} nabla T cdot hat{n} dS = int_Omega f dV.$$

Is the temperature gradient completely analagous to the electric static field? Is it like a force pushing outwards? In electrostatics the flux is out of $Omega$ is always due to the charge density $rho$. Is $f$ some kind of density in thermostatics? Charge density can be thought of as a contiuum of charges, but what is $f$ a continuum of?

Even though there is a certain similarity between the two equations, the origins are quite different. Maxwell's equations can be derived from a gauge theory, while the heat equation is a special case of a diffusion phenomenon (and hence a special case of the more general diffusion equation). Also note that the more general expression of the heat equation is

$$rho c_pfrac{partial T}{partial t} - nablacdot(kappanabla T) = dot q$$

where $rho$ is the mass density, $c_p$ is the specific heat capacity, $dot q$ is the volumetric heat source, and $kappa$ is, in general, a tensor. If we look for stationary solutions (i.e. $partial_tT = 0$), for a homogeneous and isotropic medium (i.e. $kappa$ is a space-wise constant scalar) then the equation becomes

$$nabla^2 T = -frac1kappadot q.$$

The RHS can still be interpreted as a density of heat source in space, much like $rho$ in the electrostatic equation is a density of electric charge (divided by $varepsilon$). However, for the heat equation, we have a time derivative, $dot q$, that alludes to a (heat) flux, which is not the case for the charge density $rho$. Indeed, the electrostatic equation is not describing a diffusion phenomenon.

Answered by Phoenix87 on January 4, 2022

## Related Questions

### Reason for why the rate of change of volume with respect to temperature at constant pressure equals the following for a van der Waals’ gas

0  Asked on April 23, 2021 by ripan-baruah

### Why does exchanging coordinates produce a phase of $pm 1$ in an identical particle wavefunction?

1  Asked on April 23, 2021

### How to derive the electric dipole spin resonance (EDSR) Hamiltonian in a slanting Zeeman field?

0  Asked on April 23, 2021

### What ice pack formula can hold the largest energy difference?

1  Asked on April 23, 2021 by zach-mierzejewski

### Time dilatation – relative movement

1  Asked on April 23, 2021 by codymanix

### Modulus of elasticity problem

2  Asked on April 23, 2021 by patrick-moloney

### Why do tea bags sometimes float and sometimes sink?

2  Asked on April 23, 2021 by mathphys

### Relation between Wigner flows and entropy

1  Asked on April 23, 2021 by alessandro-m-agostinelli

### Why is the translational symmetry broken?

3  Asked on April 23, 2021

### Center of Mass/Torque

1  Asked on April 23, 2021 by omniscient

### How to visualize the $U(1)$ instanton event in (2+1)D compact lattice gauge field?

0  Asked on April 23, 2021

### Is this a correct way of thinking about voltage?

3  Asked on April 23, 2021

### Why must there always exist a real particle with the same mass of the virtual particle of a certain force field?

1  Asked on April 23, 2021

### Does the geometry of a lever alter the behavior of rotation

1  Asked on April 23, 2021

2  Asked on April 23, 2021

### Is there a way to describe oscillations without referencing trigonometry?

2  Asked on April 23, 2021 by polytheneman

### Problem 1.2 (E&M Purcell & Morin) Zero force from a triangle, multiple solutions?

0  Asked on April 23, 2021 by freddy90

### How to find magnetic field due to current in a circular loop of conducting wire at any arbitrary point in its plane?

0  Asked on April 23, 2021

### Electric Field at center of hollow sphere split into two hemispheres

2  Asked on April 23, 2021

### Rotation of a Spinor

3  Asked on April 23, 2021