Physics Asked by Adeel on December 24, 2020
Refer to this image showing the temperature of a metal pipe at the inlet and the outlet:
The temperature $T(z,t)$ is a function of the length $z$ and time $t$. Let the average temperature be
$$T_mathrm{avg}(t)=frac{1}{2}big(T(a,t)+T(b,t)big).$$
Integrating the partial derivative of $T$ with respect to $t$, $frac{partial T}{partial t}$ over the entire length of the pipe (from $z=a$ to $z=b$) and applying Leibniz’s rule, we should get
$$int_{z=a}^{z=b}frac{partial}{partial t}T(z,t)dz=frac{d}{dt}int_{z=a}^{z=b}T(z,t)dz-T(b,t)frac{db}{dt}+T(a,t)frac{da}{at}.$$
In this paper (eqs. (21) and (22)), the result is reported as follows:
$$int_{z=a}^{z=b}frac{partial}{partial t}T(z,t)dz=(b-a)frac{d}{dt}T_mathrm{avg}(t)+big(T(a,t)-T_mathrm{avg}(t)big)frac{da}{dt}+big(T_mathrm{avg}(t)-T(b,t)big)frac{db}{dt}.$$
Are the two equivalent? How to correctly solve this integral? Thanks!
Note: The integral in this question is only a portion of a larger integration problem in the energy balance, not reported for brevity. Equations (21) and (22) in the reference describe the complete energy balance.
This answer is based on the original answer here. Some supplemental details relevant to the problem are added.
Referring to the original problem, let $T(z,t)$ vary linearly with $z$ as shown in the following figure:
As proposed in the original solution, integrating integral of the partial derivative of $T$ from $a$ to $b$ and applying Leibniz's Rule: begin{align} int_{a}^{b}frac{partial}{partial t}T(z,t)dz&=int_{a}^{b}frac{partial}{partial t}big(T(z,t)-T_mathrm{avg}(t)+T_mathrm{avg}(t)big)dz\ &=int_{a}^{b}frac{partial}{partial t}T_mathrm{avg}(t)dz + underbrace{int_{a}^{b}frac{partial}{partial t}big(T(z,t)-T_mathrm{avg}(t)big)dz}_text{apply Leibniz Rule}\ &=(b-a)frac{d}{dt}T_mathrm{avg}(t)\ &quad+underbrace{frac{d}{dt}int_{a}^{b}big(T(z,t)-T_mathrm{avg}(t)big)dz+big(T(a,t)-T_mathrm{avg}(t)big)frac{da}{dt}+big(T_mathrm{avg}(t)-T(b,t)big)frac{db}{dt}.}_text{Leibniz's Rule applied} end{align}
The area under the curve in the figure (shaded green) can be found using the integral $int_{a}^{b}T(z,t)dz$. Approximating the curve with a straight line, we can write
begin{align} int_{a}^{b}T(z,t)dz&approxunderbrace{frac{1}{2}(b-a)big(T(b,t)-T(a,t)big)}_text{area of top triangle}+underbrace{T(a,t)(b-a)}_text{area of bottom rectangle}\ &=frac{1}{2}big(T(a,t)+T(b,t)big)(b-a)=(b-a)T_mathrm{avg}(t). end{align}
Thus, the second term in the third equality of the first equation vanishes, and the desired result is obtained: $$int_{a}^{b}frac{partial}{partial t}T(z,t)dzapprox(b-a)frac{d}{dt}T_mathrm{avg}(t)+big(T(a,t)-T_mathrm{avg}(t)big)frac{da}{dt}+big(T_mathrm{avg}(t)-T(b,t)big)frac{db}{dt}.$$
Correct answer by Adeel on December 24, 2020
2 Asked on May 25, 2021 by devashsih-kaushik
2 Asked on May 25, 2021 by greasytoothbee
energy conservation fluid dynamics harmonic oscillator newtonian mechanics potential energy
1 Asked on May 25, 2021
general relativity gravity lagrangian formalism metric tensor tensor calculus
0 Asked on May 25, 2021 by ilp
1 Asked on May 25, 2021 by arj
electric circuits electrical engineering electricity home experiment power
2 Asked on May 25, 2021 by roflmfao
2 Asked on May 25, 2021
dimensional regularization feynman diagrams quantum electrodynamics quantum field theory self energy
1 Asked on May 25, 2021 by david-anderson
2 Asked on May 25, 2021 by unrulytank
2 Asked on May 25, 2021
electric fields electricity electromagnetic induction electromagnetism magnetic fields
3 Asked on May 25, 2021 by liquid_-nitrogen
0 Asked on May 25, 2021 by mmu_sdu
2 Asked on May 25, 2021
condensed matter metals solid state physics temperature thermodynamics
1 Asked on May 25, 2021 by ayush-bhardwaj
black holes relativistic jets space special relativity supernova
2 Asked on May 25, 2021
aerodynamics drag newtonian mechanics projectile rocket science
1 Asked on May 25, 2021 by rinchen-chosdol
experimental physics experimental technique geometric optics lenses optics
1 Asked on May 25, 2021 by faham-j
2 Asked on May 25, 2021 by walter-bislin
Get help from others!
Recent Answers
Recent Questions
© 2023 AnswerBun.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP