TransWikia.com

In the equation for the magnetic field caused by a single moving point charge, is the degree of $|r|$ in the denominator 2 or 3?

Physics Asked by Sanskar Jain on July 29, 2021

I just wanted to ask what the correct formula for the Magnetic Field around a single moving point charge is. In most places I have seen it written as $$vec{B} = frac{mu_0}{4pi} frac{qvec{v} times vec{r}}{r^2}$$ in many places however in some places such as this and this they say it is $$vec{B} = frac{mu_0}{4pi} frac{qvec{v} times vec{r}}{r^3}.$$ Could someone please clarify which one is the right one?

2 Answers

You've written the first equation wrong, it's actually $hat{mathbf{r}}$, not $vec{mathbf{r}},$ i.e. it's the unit vector in the $mathbf{r}$ direction. Clearly, in this case, both equations are the same, if you multiply the first by $|mathbf{r}|$, since $rhat{mathbf{r}} = vec{mathbf{r}}$.

If you have trouble remembering which of the two is "right", dimensional analysis is your friend. Let's say all you remember are Maxwell's Equations (a very good practice, in my opinion). Then you'd know that $$nabla times mathbf{B} = mu_0 mathbf{j}.$$ Looking at the above equation dimensionally, you should see that the dimensions of $mathbf{B}$ are:

$$L^{-1}[B] = [mu_0] [j] = [mu_0] [I] L^{-2},$$

where I've used the fact that the curl is a derivative with respect to position, and that $j$ is the current ($I$) density. Now, with the definition of current as being charge per unit time, I'll leave it to you to show that: $$[B] = [mu_0], [q v], L^{-2},$$

meaning that of the two equations as you've written them in your question, only the second could be dimensionally consistent. (Of course, dimensional consistency is no guarantee that it's the right equation! It just helps filter obviously wrong ones.)

Correct answer by Philip on July 29, 2021

You miswrote the first of the two.

$$vec{B} = frac{mu_0}{4pi} frac{qvec{v} times hat{r}}{r^2} = frac{mu_0}{4pi} frac{qvec{v} times vec{r}}{r^3}$$ because $$hat{r}=frac{vec{r}}{r}impliesfrac{hat{r}}{r^2}=frac{vec{r}}{r^3}$$ where $hat{r}$ is the unit vector in the $r$ direction.

Answered by Mauro Giliberti on July 29, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP