TransWikia.com

Why is the speed of light ignored in this formula?

Physics Asked by lordnoob on February 17, 2021

I’m trying to follow this worked example from my lecturer.

Here’s the question:

question

and here’s the answer to part 1:

enter image description here

When I was attempting this without looking at the answer, I did correctly identify the formula to be used, but I got an answer about seven orders of magnitude off. It seems that the lecturer’s answer comes from ignoring the speed of light in the formula. It seems there’s no other way to get there; the square root term produces a complex number with magnitudes $10^1 + 10^{-1}i$, so you need the frequency derived from the wavelength of order $10^{-9}$ which has a magnitude of $10^7$ to get the result shown in the official mark scheme. Obviously if you then divide the frequency by the speed of light that cuts the magnitude down to $10^1$ leaving you with a complex number that has nowhere near the required magnitudes of $10^7$ or $10^6$.

Sure enough, once I exclude the speed of light from the calculation, I get his result exactly. This isn’t a mistake, since he does it on a number of other occasions when using the same formula.

Is this some kind of convention (i.e. a unique system of units — I have heard that theoretical physicists will often work in unit systems where $c = 1$, but this was never explicitly mentioned) or is there some underlying physics that I don’t know?

One Answer

You don't need the speed of light: $$ k_x=frac{omega}{c}sqrt{frac{epsilon_d epsilon_m}{epsilon_d+epsilon_m}}=frac{2pi}{lambda}sqrt{frac{epsilon_d epsilon_m}{epsilon_d+epsilon_m}}, $$ since $$ omega=2pinu ,,,text{and},,,c=lambdanu. $$ Or you could simply say: $$ k_x=k_{rm Vak}cdot n=frac{2pi}{lambda}cdotsqrt{frac{epsilon_d epsilon_m}{epsilon_d+epsilon_m}}. $$ How did you use the speed of light if you just know $omega$ thrue $lambda$, which would take c away (if you know what I mean).

Answered by Roger on February 17, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP