TransWikia.com

Why did China impose the new national security law on Hong Kong now?

Politics Asked on October 2, 2021

Beijing’s "authoritarian rule" has always had issues with Hong Kong’s democracy, and with this national security law it’s clear that there was essentially no involvement by the Hong Kong government when it was drafted.

Why did China wait until now to pass it? Why not do it last year during all the protests, or the year before? Xi Jinping doesn’t need anyone’s permission to do this.

3 Answers

My guess:

The CCP fear that their grasp is slipping. They struggle keeping people's minds captive now that information is harder to contain and control.

There's a reason why photos from 1989 of the unarmed man facing down a column of armored tanks in Tiananmen square are banned.

Any dissent is seen as a grave danger to their one-party authoritarian state. It is swiftly beaten down to firmly "discourage" critical views in fear of "infecting" people with a notion of freedom.

Citizens of Hong Kong enjoyed many freedoms denied the rest of the Chinese people. Like freedom of expression. Freedom to criticize the CCP. etc.

Then this law went into effect, and now masses of protesters get arrested for wanting the right to speak their mind freely.

Answered by svin83 on October 2, 2021

To add to bytebuster's answer, it seems that even China scholars fail to see a specific reason for timing, besides the obvious taking advantage of the pandemic crisis.

The CCP surely knew there would be repercussions of the likes of US removing special status to Hong Kong, but the current situation might allow Chinese government and businesses to compensate for the outflow of capital in HKSE and markets in general. Only time will tell, but it seems to work thus far .

Answered by J.C on October 2, 2021

This question comes from an assumption that Chinese government acts on its own free will, "not needing anyone's permission".

In fact, China is (and was, one year ago, and will be, 27 years after today) bound by its Constitutional principle colloquially known as "One country, two systems" introduced by Deng Xiaoping.
This principle is based on the internationally-acknowledged agreement signed as part of The transfer of sovereignty over Hong Kong back in 1997 and is valid till 2047.

The newly introduced National Security Law contradicts provisions of this constitutional principle:

China’s decision to impose the new national security law on Hong Kong lies in direct conflict with its international obligations under the principles of the legally-binding, UN-registered Sino-British Joint Declaration. The proposed law would undermine the One Country, Two Systems framework.
Joint statement from UK Foreign Secretary Dominic Raab, Australian Foreign Minister Marise Payne, Canadian Foreign Minister François-Philippe Champagne, and US Secretary of State Michael Pompeo.

It is not publicly known why exactly China chose to obey its Constitutional principle before and broke it only this time, so the rest of the question will probably remain unanswered unless some official statement is released.

Answered by bytebuster on October 2, 2021

Add your own answers!

Ask a Question

Get help from others!

© 2024 TransWikia.com. All rights reserved. Sites we Love: PCI Database, UKBizDB, Menu Kuliner, Sharing RPP