I’ve been thinking about starting a quadcopter project, maybe building it from scratch. One of the main barriers-to-entry for me is the motors: it seems like most quadcopters use brushless motors. I have some experience with DC motors and using PWM signals to regulate speed, but no experience with brushless motors. As I understand it, brushless motors are more expensive than the typical DC motor I would use on a land robot, and they also require Electronic Speed Controllers (ESCs), which seem to make them (from my perspective) even more expensive and more complicated to use.
So, my question: what is it about brushless motors that make them useful in a quadcopter? Is it more torque, less weight, something to do with efficiency? And would it be significantly harder (or even possible) to achieve lift using DC motors instead?
For the smallest (and cheapest) of multicopters, DC brushed motors are well in use: http://www.rcgroups.com/forums/showthread.php?t=2009496 They are coreless motors1 and have very little inertia, can accelerate very quickly and are perfectly suited for high frquency PWM (we drive them with up to 32kHz). You can achieve more than 3:1 power:weight ratio on a sub 50g AUW airframe. Driving those motors is a lot simpler than a brushless motor, you basically just need a transistor and a capacitor.
That applies to micro copters, brushless technology didn't catch up in that weight class (yet). Probably just a question of time. The first micro brushless systems are available, but they cost many times more than coreless motors and don't offer more performance (yet).
For larger quads: no question, brushless is king. But for the micro and nano-quads, its awesome to have these cheap motors to crash with confidence ;)
Answered by benedikt on January 6, 2022
Most motors on quadcopters are outrunners. In outrunner motors, the rotating part is on the outside, and not the inside (as opposed to the inrunner motors). Because of this layout this type of motors can generate much more torque. High torque is required for quadcopters, since you balance by changing the revolutions of the motor. The higher your torque the faster you can change the speed of your propellers. High torque also means you don't need a gearbox, and save a lot of mass. Outrunners are not very practical for brushed commutation, as it would require lots of wires and additional contacts. Hence most of the outrunners are brushless.
Answered by Jakob on January 6, 2022
The brushless motors are way more powerful for their weight than available brushed motors, and they last longer.
Power to weight ratio is king, in an aircraft.
Answered by TimWescott on January 6, 2022
4 Asked on December 22, 2021 by king-amada
1 Asked on December 17, 2021 by karol-wajs
1 Asked on December 17, 2021 by assam-alzookery
1 Asked on December 17, 2021 by mauricio-moreno
1 Asked on December 7, 2021 by dong-jae-lee
3 Asked on December 4, 2021 by nikita-semenov
2 Asked on November 30, 2021 by abdullah-ansari
1 Asked on November 28, 2021 by oscarm
1 Asked on November 28, 2021 by hamedmh
1 Asked on November 28, 2021 by shubham-wani
1 Asked on November 28, 2021
2 Asked on October 3, 2021
1 Asked on October 3, 2021 by astghik-hakobyan
2 Asked on October 3, 2021 by oualid
1 Asked on October 3, 2021 by j_f
0 Asked on October 3, 2021 by rrrruo
Get help from others!