# How does steel deteriorate in translunar space?

Space Exploration Asked by Camille Goudeseune on December 18, 2020

To confirm the identity of a 1966 Centaur booster returning near earth in 2020, NASA took some spectroscopy observations. They didn’t match those of the same metal (301 stainless steel) on earth, apparently due to the booster’s 54 years in "harsh" space. But they did more closely match observations of a similar 1971 booster that stayed near Earth.

How/why did the steel’s spectral signature change? Something about radiation rather than chemical reactions? Heating/cooling cycles? Outgassing of trace carbon and nitrogen?

Did it really change so much that it could be confused with something like a metal-bearing asteroid? High-chromium steel, of whatever type and in whatever condition, is quite different from the usual nickel-iron stuff we see out there.

(Addendum: does this make stainless steel a poor choice for missions longer than a decade or so?)

The spectral data came from the surface of the material only a few atoms thick which is exposed to hard vacuum. The solar wind has ions of many materials. It is mostly hydrogen, which as an ion is just a proton. Or hydrogen atoms. Either one can react. The solar wind is not very energetic but it contains small amounts of other elements like oxygen and nitrogen, as well as alpha particles which in this case are just helium ions.

Hydrogen is so small that it can slip in among the iron and chromium and nickel and carbon of stainless steel and cause embrittlement that weakens it, among other effects (which is why hydrogen pipelines are not common). Things that change the properties of a material will change its spectrum, and may also show a long term effect from the solar wind that is not the same as surface reactions or collections.

Given enough time the Solar Wind should tarnish or in some way chemically effect the surface of steel. Also, the extreme heating and cooling cycles might also change the steel structure with atomic migration.

Correct answer by C. Towne Springer on December 18, 2020

Light interacts with fresh metal surfaces in only the first few atomic layers. What makes metals "metals" is the very high electron density, and we can think of that electron "plasma" as having such a high plasma frequency that the light barely penetrates a tiny fraction of a wavelength before being re-radiated backwards by all those electrons vibrating along with the incident electric field.

See Wikipedia's Skin effect. In the plot below we can see that even at a radio frequency of 1 MHz an electromagnetic wave's fields will have dropped by 1/e in only 10 microns when incident on a smooth, polished surface of 304 stainless steel (we can assume 301 to be similar). It drops as $$1/ sqrt{f}$$ so for red light of 600 nm or 5E+14 Hz that line would reach about 1 Angstrom. We can't do that because we have to take microscopic plasma density effects and other goodies into consideration, but it works out about right. If we wanted a more accurate answer we'd have to look up the complex index of refraction $$n + ik$$ and then calculate the attenuation coefficient.

### But I digress

because the surface of a rocket ship is not an atomically smooth polished surface even before launch. Even for stainless steel will be some contaminants adsorbed on the surface and some of the impurities will be oxidized, those "nooks and crannies" of realistic surfaces will have wavelength-dependent scattering effects.

Put it in deep space for 50 years and the effects of micrometeorites will modify the surface and that of ultraviolet light and the continuous onslaught of charged particles and neutrals from the Sun will have implanted and modified the top several tens of nanometers of the surface so much as to make the electronic structure and optical response very different than stainless that's remained on Earth.

### The operative concept here

is "the top several tens of nanometers" which is pretty much all that the solar wind will effect.

This has no effect on 304 stainless steel's structural properties.

If it were a front-surface telescope mirror or even a dish for a sub-millimeter radio telescope, it would matter optically, but not structurally.

Wikimedia's File Skin_depth_by_Zureks.png

Answered by uhoh on December 18, 2020

## Related Questions

### Engine configuration for lander

0  Asked on September 28, 2021 by navoneel-karmakar

### Could the Space Shuttles other than Enterprise easily do drop tests from the Shuttle Carrier Aircraft?

0  Asked on September 28, 2021

### Procedure to deal with the death of Apollo astronaut during a lunar mission

1  Asked on September 28, 2021

### Altitude at which Falcon boosters go subsonic during reentry

0  Asked on September 28, 2021 by george-knap

### Why is geosynchronous orbit an altitude, rather than a velocity?

8  Asked on September 28, 2021

### Cyclotron engines as a means of thrust for interplanetary travel?

2  Asked on September 28, 2021 by dualredlaugh

### Why does the video feed always fail during Falcon 9 landings?

3  Asked on September 28, 2021

### If the SpaceX drone ship’s camera feed gets disrupted every landing, why cant they throw the antennae off the ship on a buoy for better reception?

3  Asked on September 28, 2021 by user1886419

### How exactly did the floor of an Apollo LM look like after EVA(s)? Seeking photo!

2  Asked on September 28, 2021 by s-m-e

### What is the cause of the data discrepancy between these two Apollo 11 Reports

2  Asked on September 28, 2021 by user20636

### Are there microclimates with better weather conditions on Mars?

1  Asked on September 28, 2021 by cornelis

### Why is a corner of InSight’s selfie cropped like this?

1  Asked on September 28, 2021

### Are there any related groups of satellites that are in a line of 6 or more in a row?

3  Asked on September 28, 2021 by dead_man_-walking

### Was there a backup plan in case the Shuttle toilet malfunctioned?

1  Asked on September 28, 2021

### Is it impossible to prevent the combustion instability by injecting the reactants at the choking condition for the liquid rocket engine?

2  Asked on September 28, 2021 by mr-kim

### Why is the supply of RTG’s running short?

3  Asked on September 28, 2021 by zaibis

### Why are spin-stabilized rockets stable?

3  Asked on September 28, 2021 by space_voyager

### Why does the government still fund SLS while SpaceX is cheaper and has the same capabilities if not better?

6  Asked on September 28, 2021

### How many US states receive large amounts of money due to SLS?

1  Asked on September 28, 2021

### What is a K-bottle?

1  Asked on September 28, 2021

### Ask a Question

Get help from others!