# What happens if a tennis player challenges a decision for his opponent

Sports Asked on October 22, 2021

Typically tennis player can challenge a certain number of decisions. If they lose the challenge, they lose one of those “challenges”, but if they are right they don’t. So, they could possibly challenge as many decisions they want as long as they are always right. In this video, however, Herbert did not have any challenge left, he asked the opponent to challenge the decision, and Herbert got the point. If Herbert had challenged the decision he would have been right and lost none of his challenges. Did his opponent lose one, since it was Herbert’s point?

If Herbert had challenged the decision he would have been right and lost none of his challenges. Did his opponent lose one, since it was Herbert’s point?

The answer is simple: Stakhovsky (the opponent) was right in his challenge. The initial call was OUT. Stakhovsky challenged this decision. He was right in his challenge, because the ball actually was IN. Therefore, he did not lose a challenge.

To whom the point is awarded is a different question based upon the final call after the review and has nothing to do with who does (not) lose a challenge.

See the relevant section of the rulebook as follows.

The rulebook can be found here: https://www.atptour.com/en/corporate/rulebook

Answered by beta on October 22, 2021

## Related Questions

### Has a top seed tennis player been disqualified from a grand slam tournament before?

2  Asked on August 22, 2021

### Maximum match point saved in a tennis match?

1  Asked on August 20, 2021

### Table Tennis Edge Protectors

1  Asked on August 18, 2021 by aaron-d

### Why did Messi pass this penalty kick?

0  Asked on August 18, 2021

### Are the British and Irish Lions tours as significant for the host country as they are for the touring side?

0  Asked on August 18, 2021 by the-footsie

### Number 5 seeds hosting NFL conference championship game

1  Asked on August 17, 2021

### In tennis how to find out the service side in the middle of the game?

2  Asked on August 16, 2021 by sr-snow

### How to beat a defender 1v1 on the wing?

3  Asked on August 16, 2021 by hassanniazi

### Why is the last stage of Le Tour de France “friendly”?

2  Asked on August 16, 2021

### Run out rules in cricket if one player doesn’t run

4  Asked on August 15, 2021 by bharat-a-chanchlani

### Rules around shepherding in football

1  Asked on August 14, 2021 by going

### Cork screwing the punch

0  Asked on August 14, 2021

### Most braces in one season in Premier League

1  Asked on August 14, 2021

### Why does “rain stop play” in cricket?

1  Asked on August 14, 2021 by rock-ape

### How to prevent a bad flip in Gymnastics?

0  Asked on August 14, 2021

### What does “92 in 43 in hundred” mean?

1  Asked on August 14, 2021 by kaz-calihan

### How are the kids who walk with players into a football match selected?

1  Asked on August 13, 2021 by venki

### Is Roger Federer’s 65 consecutive Grand Slams a record?

1  Asked on August 13, 2021

### Why position of racers in this track not in order?

1  Asked on August 12, 2021

### How/Should a referee signal the ball is out of play if there are no AR or CL?

1  Asked on August 12, 2021 by hedgehog-ninja